Difference between revisions of "1033: Formal Logic"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Created page with explanation from the blog with an addenda from commenter Biks)
 
m (Transcript: fixed a word)
 
(15 intermediate revisions by 13 users not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
 
| title    = Formal Logic
 
| title    = Formal Logic
 
| image    = formal_logic.png
 
| image    = formal_logic.png
| imagesize =
 
 
| titletext = Note that this implies you should NOT honk solely because I stopped for a pedestrian and you're behind me.
 
| titletext = Note that this implies you should NOT honk solely because I stopped for a pedestrian and you're behind me.
 
}}
 
}}
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
The key part of this comic is "IFF", which in {{w|formal logic}} means "if and only if""If and only if" represents a formal logic connector that the result is that the truth of either one of the connected statements requires the truth of the other, i.e., either both statements are true, or both are false.  In the comic, if someone honks at this car, it means they like formal logic, there is not any other possible reason per this bumper sticker. (As we see in the image text.)
+
This comic is a riff on bumper stickers that say "honk if you love ____". Here, the subject is {{w|Mathematical logic|formal logic}}, but the word "if" is replaced with a formal logic term "{{w|If and only if|iff}}," which means "if and only if".
  
The joke is the contained self reference. You have to love formal logic to take the sticker serious and honk for exclusively that reason.
+
"If and only if" sets a condition which must be met before a procedure is allowed. In this case, you must love formal logic (condition) in order to be allowed to honk (procedure). The title text further elaborates on this, saying in essence: "Don't honk at me just because you're impatient that I stopped for a pedestrian."
  
But if you don’t love formal logic you would dislike the sticker at all and try to do something contradictory. And now the problem begins: If you don’t honk to contradict the sticker completely you automatically follow its instruction. So, there is nothing you can do except starting to love formal logic.
+
The joke is the contained self-reference. You have to love formal logic to take the sticker seriously and honk for exclusively that reason. In fact, by logic you MUST honk if you love formal logic. The title text reveals the sticker is actually there to stop people from honking at him altogether, because Randall understandably hates it when he yields for pedestrians only to get honked at by some impatient driver behind him; the ONLY reason you're allowed to honk is to declare your love for formal logic.
 +
 
 +
==Transcript==
 +
:[The rear end of a car (with an unreadable license plate), with a bumper sticker above the tailpipe to the right:]
 +
:Honk iff you love  
 +
:<big>formal logic</big>
  
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
{{comic discussion}}
 +
 +
[[Category:Logic]]
 +
[[Category:Math]]

Latest revision as of 14:35, 8 December 2017

Formal Logic
Note that this implies you should NOT honk solely because I stopped for a pedestrian and you're behind me.
Title text: Note that this implies you should NOT honk solely because I stopped for a pedestrian and you're behind me.

Explanation[edit]

This comic is a riff on bumper stickers that say "honk if you love ____". Here, the subject is formal logic, but the word "if" is replaced with a formal logic term "iff," which means "if and only if".

"If and only if" sets a condition which must be met before a procedure is allowed. In this case, you must love formal logic (condition) in order to be allowed to honk (procedure). The title text further elaborates on this, saying in essence: "Don't honk at me just because you're impatient that I stopped for a pedestrian."

The joke is the contained self-reference. You have to love formal logic to take the sticker seriously and honk for exclusively that reason. In fact, by logic you MUST honk if you love formal logic. The title text reveals the sticker is actually there to stop people from honking at him altogether, because Randall understandably hates it when he yields for pedestrians only to get honked at by some impatient driver behind him; the ONLY reason you're allowed to honk is to declare your love for formal logic.

Transcript[edit]

[The rear end of a car (with an unreadable license plate), with a bumper sticker above the tailpipe to the right:]
Honk iff you love
formal logic


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

- What can we learn from this? - I've learned that everyone who drives a car loves Formal Logic that if they press a horn actuator while driving, a horn will sound (Thank you Mr. XKCD). Now can I comment if I love your undeniable genius and your unexpected life's lessons? - E-inspired (talk) 14:36, 28 February 2013 (UTC)

"So, there is nothing you can do except starting to love formal logic" That isn't what this comic means. It means "I am a fan of formal logic, and if you are too, you may honk to indicate this. If you honk for any other reason at all, don't be surprised if I jam a pitchfork up your ass." Re-write, please. 108.162.219.58 08:37, 10 February 2014 (UTC)

Why would you even think that is correct? -Pennpenn 108.162.249.205 03:19, 29 January 2015 (UTC)
Elementary, my dear 108.162.219.58! 108.162.254.148 19:50, 8 February 2015 (UTC)
It does not say "honk when you ..." 141.101.104.55 16:54, 19 May 2015 (UTC)

So, what do you do if you hate formal logic? Honk twice? 141.101.104.113 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)