Difference between revisions of "962: The Corliss Resolution"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(added some wiki links and paradox/resolution part)
(Official transcript explicitly states it is a Youtube video)
(7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
 
| title    = The Corliss Resolution
 
| title    = The Corliss Resolution
 
| image    = the_corliss_resolution.png
 
| image    = the_corliss_resolution.png
| imagesize =
 
 
| titletext = And no avian society ever develops space travel because it's impossible to focus on calculus when you could be outside flying.
 
| titletext = And no avian society ever develops space travel because it's impossible to focus on calculus when you could be outside flying.
 
}}
 
}}
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
{{w|Jeb Corliss}} is a professional BASE jumper and wingsuit flyer (similar to the wingsuit you can see in the 4th frame). Corliss has jumped from a lot of different buildings and monuments in the world. Hence, the Corliss Resolution.
+
{{w|Jeb Corliss}} is a professional BASE jumper and {{w|wingsuit}} flyer, like in the fourth panel. Corliss has jumped from a lot of different buildings and monuments in the world. Hence, the Corliss Resolution.
  
In this comic, which is well explained by its own captions - life in general decides to find an activity that is more fun than survival, like flying off a cliff in a wingsuit, rather than working on space colonization.  And as the image text adds on to that, flying is more fun that working on calculus.
+
The {{w|Fermi paradox}} is an astronomical problem that states: "The universe is large enough that many planets should have extraterrestrial intelligent life. Why, then, haven't we detected any signs of it?" The paradox has numerous hypothetical solutions — some say that life is much rarer than we think, and others suggest that civilizations will eventually destroy themselves (as mentioned in the comic).
  
In science, a {{w|paradox}} is a contradiction between multiple apparently true statements. A {{w|Resolution (logic)|resolution}} is an explanation that attempts to resolve the contradiction.
+
Randall proposes another solution to the Fermi paradox: before they can develop space travel and the like, civilizations will inevitably invent an "activity more fun than survival." That is, something fun that's also very dangerous, such as flying off a cliff in a wingsuit.
  
==Transcript==
+
As said in the title text, a being that can already fly (hence "avian society") would probably prefer flying around outside over developing the tools needed for space colonization.
{{w|Fermi paradox|The Fermi Paradox}}: Planets are so common that life should be too. So where is it?
 
:[A person with an unusual suit runs.]
 
  
 +
See [[384: The Drake Equation]] for another comic about intelligent life in the universe.
  
:Well, now we know.  It's not that life inevitably destroys itself with war.
+
==Transcript==
:[The person keeps running.]
+
:[Cueball with an unusual suit runs right with a small cloud behind his legs. The frame of the panel is only two thirds the normal height and above the frame is the text from the narrator:]
 +
:Narrator: The Fermi Paradox: Planets are so common that life should be too. So where is it?
  
 +
:[Cueball keeps running with the small cloud behind his legs. Above him there are two frames with narration:]
 +
:Narrator: Well, now we know.
 +
:Narrator: It's not that life inevitably destroys itself with war.
  
:It's just that it takes longer to develop space colonization.
+
:[Cueball leaps into the air off a jagged cliff edge with gray cliffs. The image frame only covers a small part of the center of this panel. Narration text is shown both above and below the image:]
:[The person leaps off a cliff]
+
:Narrator: It's just that it takes longer to develop space colonization.
:Than it does to invent an activity..
+
:Narrator: Than it does to invent an activity
  
 +
:[A Youtube video is shown with the usual icons in the black bar below the image; play, volume, full screen etc. The video shows Cueball soaring downwards as indicated with four speed lines behind his spread out arms and legs. The strange suit has opened up revealing it to be a wingsuit. The sound is on and Cueball can be heard. Above the video frame there is a final narration text in a frame. Two people are watching the video together off-panel and their comments are shown below in two voice bubbles with arrows pointing left and right.]
 +
:Narrator: More fun than survival.
 +
:Cueball: Wheeeee!
 +
:Off-panel voice #1: Holy crap.
 +
:Off-panel voice #2: I don't care how dangerous it is. I have to try it.
  
..more fun than survival.
+
{{comic discussion}}
:[Youtube video of the person, with the suit opening up into a wingsuit. As this is youtube, the comments have not been shown.  Two people are watching the video offpanel.]
 
:Person 1: Holy crap.
 
:Person 2: I don't care how dangerous it is. I have to try it.
 
  
{{comic discussion}}
+
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 +
[[Category:Comics featuring real people]] <!-- mentioning of Corliss  -->
 +
[[Category:Wingsuit]]
 +
[[Category:Astronomy]]
 +
[[Category:Space]]

Revision as of 20:05, 8 September 2016

The Corliss Resolution
And no avian society ever develops space travel because it's impossible to focus on calculus when you could be outside flying.
Title text: And no avian society ever develops space travel because it's impossible to focus on calculus when you could be outside flying.

Explanation

Jeb Corliss is a professional BASE jumper and wingsuit flyer, like in the fourth panel. Corliss has jumped from a lot of different buildings and monuments in the world. Hence, the Corliss Resolution.

The Fermi paradox is an astronomical problem that states: "The universe is large enough that many planets should have extraterrestrial intelligent life. Why, then, haven't we detected any signs of it?" The paradox has numerous hypothetical solutions — some say that life is much rarer than we think, and others suggest that civilizations will eventually destroy themselves (as mentioned in the comic).

Randall proposes another solution to the Fermi paradox: before they can develop space travel and the like, civilizations will inevitably invent an "activity more fun than survival." That is, something fun that's also very dangerous, such as flying off a cliff in a wingsuit.

As said in the title text, a being that can already fly (hence "avian society") would probably prefer flying around outside over developing the tools needed for space colonization.

See 384: The Drake Equation for another comic about intelligent life in the universe.

Transcript

[Cueball with an unusual suit runs right with a small cloud behind his legs. The frame of the panel is only two thirds the normal height and above the frame is the text from the narrator:]
Narrator: The Fermi Paradox: Planets are so common that life should be too. So where is it?
[Cueball keeps running with the small cloud behind his legs. Above him there are two frames with narration:]
Narrator: Well, now we know.
Narrator: It's not that life inevitably destroys itself with war.
[Cueball leaps into the air off a jagged cliff edge with gray cliffs. The image frame only covers a small part of the center of this panel. Narration text is shown both above and below the image:]
Narrator: It's just that it takes longer to develop space colonization.
Narrator: Than it does to invent an activity
[A Youtube video is shown with the usual icons in the black bar below the image; play, volume, full screen etc. The video shows Cueball soaring downwards as indicated with four speed lines behind his spread out arms and legs. The strange suit has opened up revealing it to be a wingsuit. The sound is on and Cueball can be heard. Above the video frame there is a final narration text in a frame. Two people are watching the video together off-panel and their comments are shown below in two voice bubbles with arrows pointing left and right.]
Narrator: More fun than survival.
Cueball: Wheeeee!
Off-panel voice #1: Holy crap.
Off-panel voice #2: I don't care how dangerous it is. I have to try it.


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

But technological development is eventually going to make wingsuit flight safe, so how are we going to explain our continued survival after that? Davidy²²[talk] 08:28, 9 March 2013 (UTC)

Rocket-Sneakers(TM) 178.105.151.131 06:59, 25 April 2013 (UTC)

When wingsuits become safe, they will become common, and will therefore not be as much fun. In the mean time, someone will have invented something else which is both fun and dangerous (like the aforementioned Rocket-Sneakers(TM)) Drmouse (talk) 13:19, 10 January 2014 (UTC)

"before they can develop space travel and the like, civilizations will inevitably invent an "activity more fun than survival." That is, something fun that's also very dangerous, such as flying off a cliff in a wing-suit."

Before they can develop space travel and the like, civilizations will have to invent an activity more fun than jumping off a cliff in a wing-suit and the like. Space travel is boring. Engineering space travel is boring with maths and work in it too. I used Google News BEFORE it was clickbait (talk) 22:22, 22 January 2015 (UTC)

"As said in the title text, a being that can already fly (hence "avian society") would probably prefer flying around outside over developing the tools needed for space colonization."

I don't think that's accurate (the logic of avian sentients choosing to not develop space travel due to the enjoyment of flying; the title text interpretation being this is fine) because that is from a non-avian sentient perspective. To a sentient avian, flying would be normal, and thus as boring as walking is to us. And if you think walking is fun, YOU are boring. -- OriginalName (talk) 02:00, 26 April 2017 (UTC) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

For one, that's the joke. For two, I would strongly encourage you to read Jonathan Livingston Seagull. 172.69.170.56 18:22, 13 November 2020 (UTC)mezimm