3104: Tukey

2025-06-20T05:25:20Z

2A02:3037:207:C0E7:79BD:5072:32B3:2360: /* Explanation */ adding exact time when he was 110.000 years

{{comic
| number = 3104
| date = June 18, 2025
| title = Tukey
| image = tukey_2x.png
| imagesize = 392x276px
| noexpand = true
| titletext = Numbers can be tricky. On the day of my 110th birthday, I'll be one day younger than John Tukey was on his.
}}

==Explanation==
{{incomplete|This page was created by THE NOMINATIVE DETERMINISM OF SOMEONE NAMED TUKEY COINING THE "BIT" WHICH ONLY NEEDS TWO KEYS TO WRITE ALL THE VALUES OF. Don't remove this notice too soon.}}

The comic gives a quote by {{w|John W. Tukey}}, an American mathematician and statistician, from his paper called ''The Future of Data Analysis'', where he discusses the importance of facing uncertainty. [[Randall]] then gives Tukey's age as 110.000 years (that is, 110 years to three decimal places) — a very precise answer to the question of "how old is Tukey?" However, when it comes to his birthday, arguably the right question in this context, he only gives the approximate answer of "sometime this week". Tukey was born on Wednesday, June 16, 1915, 110 years and 2 days before the release of this comic on Wednesday, June 18, 2025. Since he died in 2000, it can be debated whether he has a birthday this week!

Since the comic is two days (or 0.54% of a year) late compared to Tukey's actual birthday, three decimal places of zero is actually inaccurate on the day of the comic's release, when he was 110.005 years old. However, sometime during this week he was exactly 110.000 years old (namely on Monday June 16, at the exact hour of his birth in 1915) — the joke being that he gives a very precise age, but not the exact time when this answer is accurate.

The title text states that Randall would be one day younger than Tukey would be on his 110th birthday. Tukey's 110th birthday (on Monday) marked 40,178 days since his birth. Randall's 110th birthday ([[1179: ISO 8601|2094-10-17]]) will occur 40,17'''7''' days after his birth, due to having only passed through {{w|Gregorian calendar|27 leap-days}} (the first in 1988, the latest in 2092) instead of Tukey's 28 instances (from 1916 to 2024, inclusive).

There are multiple different definitions of the year, however. The one most applied to birthdays is "a whole year has passed when it's the same calendar day", but the usual scientific/mathematical value is the tropical year of 365.2422 days (the time between the same two equinoxes) which smears the leap day across four years (which might impact the last digit of the calculation), and also the sidereal year of 365.2564 days (the time it takes the Sun to return to the same place in the sky), which differs due to {{w|Axial precession|precession of the equinoxes}}. The difference between the tropical and sidereal calculations over 110 years is about 1.5 days, so for this alternative definition of the year, we get a different answer for which day is 110, but it still remains "this week". There's also the average length of a year in the {{w|Gregorian calendar}} (the calendar in use now), which averages 365.2425 days over the 400-year cycle of the calendar. Tukey suggests we shouldn't get hung up on this, but those who happen to be born on 29th February may disagree.

==Transcript==
{{incomplete transcript|Transcribed by an idiot. Don't remove this notice too soon.}}

:[Text formatted as a block quote]

:"Far better an approximate answer to the ''right'' question, which is often vague, than an ''exact'' answer to the wrong question, which can always be made precise."

:John W. Tukey
:''The Future of Data Analysis (1962)''

:Caption below the comic:
:Happy approximate birthday to John Tukey, author of my favorite statistics quote, who was born 110.000 years ago sometime this week.

{{comic discussion}}<noinclude>
[[Category:Comics featuring real people]]
[[Category:Statistics]]

explain xkcd - User contributions [en]

3104: Tukey