Editing 309: Shopping Teams

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
[[Randall]] is comparing the ways different people look at choosing between similar products. In the first example, which Randall considers "bad," two "non-nerds" look at two products (without a description of any kind) and instantly decide which one they want. In the second example, which is considered "good," one of the two is a {{w|Nerd|nerd}}, and the other one is a non-nerd. The non-nerd instantly picks one of the products, but the nerd evaluates the two and decides that the other one is better because it's a better deal. In both the first two cases, the pair is able to easily come to a decision.
+
[[Randall]] is comparing the ways different people look at choosing between similar products. In the first example, which Randall considers "bad", two "non-nerds" look at two products (without a description of any kind) and instantly decide which one they want. In the second example, which is considered "good", one of the two is a {{w|Nerd|nerd}} and the other one is a non-nerd. The non-nerd instantly picks one of the products but the nerd evaluates the two and decides that the other one is better because it's a better deal. In both the first two cases, the pair are able to easily come to a decision.
  
However, in the third example, two nerds are comparing the two boxes, and both of them overanalyse the various merits and drawbacks on each of the two boxes. They are still there two hours later, unable to reach a clear agreement on which of the two boxes they wish to buy. One nerd comments that their definition of value is unclear, suggesting that the discussion has gone on for so long because they are re-evaluating their definitions over something too trivial. Some might perceive this as typical "nerd" behaviour, overanalysing a problem that is in actual fact quite trivial, such as the decision whether to buy one box or the other virtually identical box. The non-nerd woman from the second situation (or perhaps the store manager in this situation), who has watched the two nerds compare the two products for hours, attempts to put this into perspective by pointing out that an unclear definition of value is not their main problem. The implication is that their real main problem is that they are unable to reach an agreement on something that makes so little difference. Or their problem could be the one described in [[1445: Efficiency]].
+
However, in the third example two nerds are comparing the two boxes and both of them over-analyse the various merits and drawbacks on each of the two boxes. They are still there two hours later, unable to reach a clear agreement on which of the two boxes they wish to buy. One nerd comments that their definition of value is unclear, suggesting the discussion has gone on for so long because they are re-evaluating their definitions over something too trivial. Some might perceive this as typical "nerd" behaviour, over-analysing a problem which is in actual fact quite trivial, such as the decision whether to buy one box or the other virtually identical box. The non-nerd woman from the second situation (or perhaps the store manager in this situation), who has watched the two nerds compare the two products for hours, attempts to put this into perspective, by pointing out that an unclear definition of value is not their main problem. The implication is that their real main problem is that they are unable to reach an agreement on something that makes so little difference. Or their problem could be the one described in [[1445: Efficiency]].
  
The title text suggests that Randall entered a similar situation attempting to buy an air conditioner with his sysadmin, short for {{w|System administrator}}. The sysadmin is a person in an organization employed to manage the computer system or network, a role that requires technical skills and intelligence. The suggestion here is that a computer programmer, like Randall, put together with a sysadmin, would spend as much attention to detail as the two nerds in the comic, laboring over which of two trivially similar products to buy.
+
The title text suggests that Randall entered a similar situation attempting to buy an air conditioner with his sysadmin, short for {{w|System administrator}}. The sysadmin is a person in an organisation employed to manage the computer system or network, a role which requires technical skills and intelligence. The suggestion here is that a computer programmer, like Randall, put together with a sysadmin, would spend as much attention to detail as the two nerds in the comic, labouring over which of two trivially similar products to buy.
  
 
Randall deals with sysadmins again in [[705: Devotion to Duty]].
 
Randall deals with sysadmins again in [[705: Devotion to Duty]].
Line 20: Line 20:
 
:<big><big>Shopping teams</big></big>
 
:<big><big>Shopping teams</big></big>
  
:[Above the first team consisting of two Cueball-like guys is written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
+
:[Above the first team consisting of two Cueball-like guys are written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
 
:<big>Bad:</big>
 
:<big>Bad:</big>
 
:Two non-nerds
 
:Two non-nerds
Line 27: Line 27:
 
:Non-nerd 2: Okay.
 
:Non-nerd 2: Okay.
  
:[Above the second team consisting of a Blondie and a Cueball-like guy is written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
+
:[Above the second team consisting of a Blondie and a Cueball-like guy, are written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
 
:<big>Good:</big>
 
:<big>Good:</big>
 
:Non-nerd + nerd
 
:Non-nerd + nerd
Line 35: Line 35:
 
:Blondie non-nerd: Okay, that one.  
 
:Blondie non-nerd: Okay, that one.  
  
:[Above the third team consisting of two Cueball-like guys is written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
+
:[Above the third team consisting of two Cueball-like guys, are written the following text (the first line written with larger letters):]
 
:<big>Very Bad:</big>
 
:<big>Very Bad:</big>
 
:Two Nerds
 
:Two Nerds
Line 47: Line 47:
 
:Later
 
:Later
  
:[The two Cueball-like guys are sitting on the floor in front of the counter, both having their laptops open and with lots of paper sheets spread around them, as well as a pen. Blondie from the second team comes in from the right and raises her arms:]
+
:[The two Cueball-like guys are sitting on the floor in front of the counter, both having their laptops open and with lots of paper sheets spread around them as well as a pen etc. Blondie from the second team comes in from the right and raises her arms:]
 
:Nerd 1: I think our main problem is our unclear definition of value.
 
:Nerd 1: I think our main problem is our unclear definition of value.
 
:Blondie non-nerd: That is not your main problem!
 
:Blondie non-nerd: That is not your main problem!

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)