Difference between revisions of "429: Fantasy"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Spelling)
m (Explanation: Much more details)
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
 +
[[Cueball]] is fantasizing about being together with [[Megan]] a girl he really wishes to be with, but he has so far not found any way to make this happen. However, in his fantasy the imaginary versions of himself and Megan quickly realize how impossible their relationship would be. First of all neither of them can remember why they are together (a typical trait of dreams, that you are suddenly in some situation but cannot remember what went before). Also Megan seems to find is very difficult to imagine them being together. Although the reasons are left unstated it is clear that it is actually Cueball who cannot himself imagine a situation that would make Megan want to be with him, and he projects this into the thoughts of his fantasy version of Megan. He himself mentions the word fantasy, which makes her realize that they are objects in a fantasy (or dream) that will soon end, ans then so will they.
  
[[Cueball]] is fantasizing about [[Megan]]. However, the imaginary versions of himself and Megan quickly realize how impossible their relationship would be (although the reasons are left unstated) and so they decide to destroy the universe they are in. This leaves Cueball confused. Rather than allow Cueball's idle daydream to end romantically, they run rampant and bring his fantasy crashing to a halt.
+
Then she decides to destroy the fantasy world they are in instead of going quietly, as she would have once this fantasy ended. She goes for burning it to the ground, and the fantasy Cueball is with her, since he has also realized that he will loose here when this fantasy ends. Rather than allow Cueball's idle daydream to end romantically, they run rampant and bring his fantasy crashing to a halt.  
  
The title text refers to the fact that Cueball would only appreciate a girl who refused an irrational reality, thus the fantasy is consistent with his personality.
+
This leaves the real Cueball confused. But in the title text Cueball realizes that he would only appreciate a girl who refused such an irrational reality, thus the fantasy is consistent with both of their personalities.
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==

Revision as of 19:53, 9 May 2015

Fantasy
I guess if she accepted irrational realities, she'd hardly be my fantasy.
Title text: I guess if she accepted irrational realities, she'd hardly be my fantasy.

Explanation

Cueball is fantasizing about being together with Megan a girl he really wishes to be with, but he has so far not found any way to make this happen. However, in his fantasy the imaginary versions of himself and Megan quickly realize how impossible their relationship would be. First of all neither of them can remember why they are together (a typical trait of dreams, that you are suddenly in some situation but cannot remember what went before). Also Megan seems to find is very difficult to imagine them being together. Although the reasons are left unstated it is clear that it is actually Cueball who cannot himself imagine a situation that would make Megan want to be with him, and he projects this into the thoughts of his fantasy version of Megan. He himself mentions the word fantasy, which makes her realize that they are objects in a fantasy (or dream) that will soon end, ans then so will they.

Then she decides to destroy the fantasy world they are in instead of going quietly, as she would have once this fantasy ended. She goes for burning it to the ground, and the fantasy Cueball is with her, since he has also realized that he will loose here when this fantasy ends. Rather than allow Cueball's idle daydream to end romantically, they run rampant and bring his fantasy crashing to a halt.

This leaves the real Cueball confused. But in the title text Cueball realizes that he would only appreciate a girl who refused such an irrational reality, thus the fantasy is consistent with both of their personalities.

Transcript

[Cueball sits hugging his knees.]
Cueball: If only there were some way we could be together.
[He fades into a thought bubble containing the next four panels.]
[Cueball and Megan are lounging on a bed.]
Megan: We're so lucky to have each other. How did it happen, anyway?
Cueball: I, uh... I don't remember.
Megan: No, really, how did we get together? It's hard to imagine it happening.
Cueball: It does strain the bounds of fantasy...
Megan: ...Fantasy? That's it!
Megan: My God, it's the only explanation: We're objects in some transient fantasy. We'll be gone when it ends!
Cueball: We'll lose each other.
Megan: Oh God.
[Megan leaps from the bed with a flaming torch.]
Megan: Well, I'm not going out quietly. I'm burning this fucking world.
Cueball: Burn the world!
Megan: Fire! Fire! Cleanse this hellish place—
[The thought ends.]
Cueball (scratching his head): ??


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

I think the "impossible" part is not their relationship, but the fact they don't remember how it happened. -- Hkmaly (talk) 23:52, 11 May 2014 (UTC)

Any particular impossibility is not explained, but I believe it is implied in Cueball's first sentence "If only there were some way we could..." implying that there is no way that they could. Brettpeirce (talk) 13:47, 24 July 2014 (UTC)

It seems like an important distinction that in the comic Megan wonders how but the description says she wonders why. The comic doesn't actually give us a reason why they cannot be together- it could be ling distance just as easily as unrequited love. Bbruzzo (talk) 18:23, 20 August 2015 (UTC)

Ive always thought this comic bears some similarities to Jorges Luis Borges' short story, The Circular Ruins