Difference between revisions of "510: Egg Drop Failure"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Polish.)
m (Explanation)
(9 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
 
| title    = Egg Drop Failure
 
| title    = Egg Drop Failure
 
| image    = egg_drop_failure.png
 
| image    = egg_drop_failure.png
| imagesize =
 
 
| titletext = I hear my brother Ricky won his school's egg drop by leaving the egg inside the hen.
 
| titletext = I hear my brother Ricky won his school's egg drop by leaving the egg inside the hen.
 
}}
 
}}
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
We all remember the egg drop from school- make some way of getting an egg to drop to the ground without breaking using the weirdest methods possible. The poor student here had an egg that was ready to hatch, and it did during the fall.  Problem is, you lose if your egg has any cracks in it.  Unfortunately birds aren't ready to fly that quickly.
+
A common competition for school-age children (e.g. in science fairs or summer camps) is the 'egg drop': each team is given an uncooked egg and an assortment of materials, e.g. newspaper, Popsicle sticks, string, tape, etc.. The challenge is to use the provided materials to build a contraption that will allow the egg to be dropped from some specified height onto a hard floor without breaking. Scoring varies wildly - common elements are speed of assembly, an accurately targetable landing, and mass of the contraption - but one near-universal requirement is that you are disqualified if the egg is broken.
  
As for the image text, dropping a hen would guarantee a win. As it is falling, the chicken will try to fly and are very good about landing softly. And most chickens lay an egg every 24 hours, so if you pick the right chicken it will lay an unbroken egg just after landing on the ground.
+
In the comic, the student pictured fails, not because of any flaw in his design, but because the egg he was given hatches during the fall! (Of course, this is exaggerated to ludicrous extents; the hatching process takes longer than the few seconds the fall would last, and the newborn chick cannot fly immediately.) However, if it magically happens, then the student would be disqualified because the egg technically broke. However, as stated above, this would be impossible.
 +
 
 +
The title text suggests an alternate strategy, one Randall hears was successful in real life: select for your egg one that has not yet been laid. The hen provides both active lift with her wings and significant padding, thus nearly guaranteeing that the egg will survive the fall. Of course, this would not be permitted in most contests, as a chicken is not one of the provided materials. And even if it were allowed, a chicken is much heavier than the usual contraptions of newspaper and string.{{Citation needed}}
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
 
:[Boy tosses contraption off of building with egg in it.]
 
:[Boy tosses contraption off of building with egg in it.]
 
:[Egg cracks and little chick flies out while people look quizzically at the hatched egg.]
 
:[Egg cracks and little chick flies out while people look quizzically at the hatched egg.]
:''Crack! Chirp, chirp''
+
:''Crack''
 +
:''Chirp, chirp''
 
:[Device with cracked egg lands on ground.]
 
:[Device with cracked egg lands on ground.]
  
Line 22: Line 24:
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Ponytail]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Ponytail]]
 +
[[Category:Animals]]
 +
[[Category:Science]]

Revision as of 09:09, 10 March 2018

Egg Drop Failure
I hear my brother Ricky won his school's egg drop by leaving the egg inside the hen.
Title text: I hear my brother Ricky won his school's egg drop by leaving the egg inside the hen.

Explanation

A common competition for school-age children (e.g. in science fairs or summer camps) is the 'egg drop': each team is given an uncooked egg and an assortment of materials, e.g. newspaper, Popsicle sticks, string, tape, etc.. The challenge is to use the provided materials to build a contraption that will allow the egg to be dropped from some specified height onto a hard floor without breaking. Scoring varies wildly - common elements are speed of assembly, an accurately targetable landing, and mass of the contraption - but one near-universal requirement is that you are disqualified if the egg is broken.

In the comic, the student pictured fails, not because of any flaw in his design, but because the egg he was given hatches during the fall! (Of course, this is exaggerated to ludicrous extents; the hatching process takes longer than the few seconds the fall would last, and the newborn chick cannot fly immediately.) However, if it magically happens, then the student would be disqualified because the egg technically broke. However, as stated above, this would be impossible.

The title text suggests an alternate strategy, one Randall hears was successful in real life: select for your egg one that has not yet been laid. The hen provides both active lift with her wings and significant padding, thus nearly guaranteeing that the egg will survive the fall. Of course, this would not be permitted in most contests, as a chicken is not one of the provided materials. And even if it were allowed, a chicken is much heavier than the usual contraptions of newspaper and string.[citation needed]

Transcript

[Boy tosses contraption off of building with egg in it.]
[Egg cracks and little chick flies out while people look quizzically at the hatched egg.]
Crack
Chirp, chirp
[Device with cracked egg lands on ground.]


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

Newborn birds can't fly. I call shenanigans on this comic. Davidy22(talk) 11:08, 22 November 2012 (UTC)

The contraption was so well built that it took several months for it to land; hence the hatching and ability to fly. flewk (talk) 00:42, 4 January 2016 (UTC)

Oh, so that's where the soup comes from! 108.162.221.64 09:29, 26 August 2015 (UTC)

I was adding a citation, but after a bit of research, an average ethiopian chicken apparently checks all the boxes in at least one egg drop competition, as long as you can fit a large grade A egg in there.--162.158.193.247 06:01, 16 July 2022 (UTC)