Difference between revisions of "881: Probability"
m (removed Category:Mat; added Category:Math using HotCat) |
m (→Transcript) |
||
Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
==Transcript== | ==Transcript== | ||
− | :[A plot of years vs. percent, with a solid and a dashed line. | + | :[A plot of years vs. percent, with a solid and a dashed line. The solid line starts at 100%, and drops constantly. The dashed line starts around 85%, rises to 95% after 5 years, then drops.] |
:[A simple table.] | :[A simple table.] | ||
Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
:10 years 77% | :10 years 77% | ||
− | :[Two people are sitting on a bench, next to an IV drip hanging from a rack. | + | :[Two people are sitting on a bench, next to an IV drip hanging from a rack. One is holding a paper.] |
− | : | + | :Cueball: You know, probability used to be my favorite branch of math |
− | : | + | :Cueball: Because it had so many real-life applications. |
:[They embrace, faces together.] | :[They embrace, faces together.] |
Revision as of 08:27, 11 November 2012
Probability |
Title text: My normal approach is useless here, too. |
Explanation
As the title text says, my normal approach is useless here.
Cueball and Megan are sitting on a hospital bed reading a piece of paper, with the statistics for breast cancer survival. It looks like Megan has just been diagnosed with breast cancer.
The dotted line represents the survival rate distribution: the higher number being centered on about 5 years, in this case with a chance of 81%. 10 years is the limit: the max survival rate expected is 10 years, with a chance of 77%.
Randall posted this blag post two months after posting this strip explaining the cancer strips.
Transcript
- [A plot of years vs. percent, with a solid and a dashed line. The solid line starts at 100%, and drops constantly. The dashed line starts around 85%, rises to 95% after 5 years, then drops.]
- [A simple table.]
- 5 years 81%
- 10 years 77%
- [Two people are sitting on a bench, next to an IV drip hanging from a rack. One is holding a paper.]
- Cueball: You know, probability used to be my favorite branch of math
- Cueball: Because it had so many real-life applications.
- [They embrace, faces together.]
Discussion
I've been through this, even though it was a little over a year ago, this strip brings me back to how I tried to rationalise the probabilities to deal with the news, and the only thing I could think of was "I want a better number, god, noodle-monster, anybody, please, give me a better number".
John 60.225.31.6 00:40, 28 September 2013 (UTC)
Can anyone please provide an update to this page on Randall's fiance's health? Apologies if this is common knowledge. I agree with John's reaction. I wanted a better number for my wife back in the spring of 2008, and got it. She survived 3 years instead of the (then) predicted average of six months for inflammatory breast cancer. We could have been just an outlier on the low probability end of the curve, but I like to think the medical community is continually improving their curves, and I am very grateful for the extra time. She passed away four days after this strip was posted - which explains why I haven't seen this strip until now.
108.162.216.228 21:26, 28 November 2013 (UTC)Grant
So, how is this incomplete? Can we remove the incompleteness mark? --173.245.53.196 13:02, 19 January 2014 (UTC)
I think the linking to the blog post is more sensitive than explaining it here. Remove tag? --141.101.98.207 14:19, 19 January 2014 (UTC)
What is the dashed line? It kind of looks like it might be the derivative of the solid line.108.162.214.53 00:39, 20 January 2014 (UTC)
I think I explained the dashed line, it's a hazard function or at least it would be a plausible hazard function for that kind of survival function. Feel free to improve the formatting or remove the incomplete tag. --Artod (talk) 07:06, 20 January 2014 (UTC)
TEN YEARS 172.69.33.179 17:38, 17 November 2020 (UTC)