Editing 1470: Kix

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
{{w|Kix (cereal)|Kix}} is an American brand of cold breakfast cereal made of extruded and expanded cornmeal. Its slogan, "Kid tested, Mother approved," is well known in the United States. However, in this brainstorming session, the word "Approved" has apparently not yet been considered. A number of possible words and phrases for the ending have been presented and {{w|Strikethrough|stricken out}}, indicating that they were rejected; each one causes the slogan to be subject to increasingly absurd and comedic interpretations:
+
This comic shows a possible brainstorming session over a marketing slogan for {{w|Kix (cereal)|Kix cereal}}, a breakfast cereal marketed to children. The cereal's actual slogan is "Kid Tested, Mother Approved", implying that kids enjoy the cereal and mothers, who are naturally concerned about the health of their children, approve of its ingredients. In this scenario, however, the word "Approved" has apparently not been considered. Instead, a number of alternative ending words and phrases have been presented and rejected.  Each word changes the meaning of the slogan in an increasingly comedic way as compared to the real slogan:
  
#'''Selected''': This word may have been chosen as a {{w|slant rhyme}} of "Tested". This word shares a definition with "Approved", and states that mothers specifically choose this cereal over others.  This phrase could also suggest that one mother ''herself'' had been chosen for some unstated purpose.
+
# '''Selected''': This word shares a definition with "Approved", and may additionally imply that mothers specifically choose this cereal over others. This word may have been chosen as a {{w|slant rhyme}} of "Tested". (Advertising slogans that contain simple rhymes tend to be more easily remembered than those that don't.) This phrase could also suggest that one mother ''herself'' had been chosen for some unstated purpose.
#'''Perfected''': It's likely that the previous word inspired someone in the brainstorming session to find a similarly positive word that rhymes with "Selected". It states that one or more mothers were directly involved in developing and refining the cereal's composition to a high degree. Much like with "Selected", this could also suggest that the mother was somehow improved to perfection during the test.
+
# '''Perfected''': It's likely that "Selected" inspired someone in the brainstorming session to find a similarly positive word.  It also mostly rhymes with "Tested", but it implies that one or more mothers were directly involved in developing and refining the cereal's composition to a high degree. (Similarly to "Selected", this could also suggest that the mother was somehow improved to perfection during the test.)
#'''Not Notified''': Relates to the world of experimental research and clinical trials. This phrase suggests that the children who tested the cereal did not obtain the required consent, which would generally involve notifying and getting permission from both parents.
+
# '''Not Notified''': Relates to the world of experimental research and clinical trials. This phrase suggests that the children who tested the cereal did so without the written consent of their parents.
#'''Watching Helplessly''': Again we can see that in a brainstorming session such the previous option may trigger this one as it is related to the dangers of testing. This phrase suggests that mothers were forced to watch their children test the cereal, and that the cereal or the test is unhealthy or dangerous.
+
# '''Watching Helplessly''': This phrase suggests that mothers were forced to watch their children test the cereal remotely (eg. in a separate room or by video camera) and had no ability to interact with their children during the test, nor any say in the test's outcome.  They may have considered it unhealthy or dangerous, but their opinions were ignored.
#'''Infected''': This may be intended to show the group dynamic of the brainstorming session as it is inspired by option one and two, as infected rhymes with both selected and perfected, and by the third option as both relate to dangerous testing. This slogan states that an infectious agent was passed to the mother as a result of the test. This could also be interpreted as the mother having introduced the infectious agent into the cereal or testing environment.
+
# '''Infected''': Another rhyming word, but this one implies that the cereal (or some other element of the test) contained an infectious agent (eg. a virus) that was passed from the child to his or her mother. This could also be interpreted as the mother having introduced the infectious agent into the cereal or testing environment, or that the mother was {{w|brainwashing|brainwashed}} in some way during the test.
# '''Consumed''': Continuing the trend of dark slogans this slogan says that the mothers were ''themselves'' consumed, perhaps by their children (by virtue of the mother being an ingredient in the cereal), the cereal itself, or something otherwise related to the test. Another possible interpretation is that the mother ate the cereal after the kid tested it, possibly because the kid did not enjoy the taste.
+
# '''Consumed''': One possible interpretation is that, whether or not the children in the study actually liked the cereal, their mothers ate it without necessarily stating any opinions on its quality.  Another interpretation is that the mothers were themselves consumed, perhaps by their children, the cereal itself, or something unrelated to the test (eg. a monster).
#'''Fucker''': This expletive is often paired with "Mother" to form the compound word "Motherfucker". In this case, the slogan changes to {{w|vocative case}}: "[This cereal has been] Kid Tested, Motherfucker!". This appears to be an "elephant" - a ponderous ending of a joke that contrasts sharply with the refined and mild humor of the previous options. The phrase itself basically only states that a child tested the cereal and implies that nothing else matters. Using a swear word on packaging of a food designed for kids is usually not a good idea. {{Citation needed}}
+
# '''Fucker''': This expletive is often paired with "Mother" to form the compound word "Motherfucker". In this case, the slogan changes to {{w|vocative case}}: "[This cereal has been] Kid Tested, Motherfucker!". This last option appears to be an "elephant" - a ponderous ending of a joke that contrasts with the comparatively refined and mild humor of the previous options. The phrase itself basically only states that a child tested the cereal and implies that nothing else is important.  
  
The title text conflates the phrase "Kid tested" with college entrance exams such as the {{w|Standardized Aptitude Test}} (SAT) or the {{w|ACT (test)|ACT}}. Instead of stating that a child tasted the cereal and gave their opinion on its quality, the cereal itself is an academic subject on which the child was tested. Randall, referring to how some parents enroll their children in special {{w|Test prep|classes or schools}} to prepare them to score well in this type of test, states that his parents extensively prepared him for a college entrance exam about Kix cereal.
+
The title text conflates the phrase "Kid tested" with college entrance exams such as the {{w|Standardized Aptitude Test}} (SAT) or the {{w|ACT (test)|ACT}}. Instead of stating that a child tasted the cereal and gave his or her opinion on its quality, the cereal itself is an academic subject on which the child was tested (again, without stating the outcome). Randall, referring to how some parents enroll their children in special {{w|test prep|classes or schools}} to prepare them to score well in this type of test, states that his parents enrolled him in schooling to prepare him to do well at a "Kix test". In this case, Randall is poking fun at the somewhat ambiguous wording of "Kid Tested" - the authors of the original slogan could have used a hyphen between the words ("Kid-Tested") to avoid this ambiguity, but this was not done.
 
 
This comic may be a commentary about the uselessness of brainstorming sessions or the bad ideas that come out of them, as they are often started with the phrase “there are no bad ideas”. As the brainstorming session continues the original meaning of the slogan is lost, much like a game of telephone, and the session becomes less productive.
 
 
 
Cereal advertising has previously been referenced in [[38: Apple Jacks]].
 
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
:[Ponytail, Megan, and Cueball are standing around a whiteboard on an easel; Ponytail and Cueball are holding red markers. The whiteboard reads:]
+
:[Ponytail, Megan, and Cueball are standing around a whiteboard. The whiteboard on easel reads:]
:[in Large] '''Kix'''
+
:'''Kix'''
:[Underlined] <u>Slogan ideas</u>
+
:<u>Slogan ideas</u>
 
:Kid Tested, Mother...
 
:Kid Tested, Mother...
  
[following lines all in red and each crossed out]
+
:<font color="red"><strike>Selected</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Selected</s></font>
+
:<strike>Perfected</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Perfected</s></font>
+
:<strike>Not notified</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Not notified</s></font>
+
:<strike>Watching helplessly</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Watching helplessly</s></font>
+
:<strike>Infected</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Infected</s></font>
+
:<strike>Consumed</strike>
:<font color="red"><s>Consumed</s></font>
+
:<strike>Fucker</strike></font>
:<font color="red"><s>Fucker</s></font>
 
  
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
[[Category:Comics with color]]
 
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Megan]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Megan]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Ponytail]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Ponytail]]
[[Category:Food]]
+
[[Category:Comics with color]]
[[Category:Kids]]
 

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)