Editing 743: Infrastructures

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
−
[[Cueball]] has sent an essay to his friend, likely [[Richard Stallman]], an advocate of free and open-source software. While the essay itself was good, Stallman worries because the essay was in the {{w|Doc (computing)|.doc}} format, the {{w|Proprietary Software|proprietary format}} that old versions of {{w|Microsoft Word}} used. He advises Cueball to use a format based on an open standard, possibly ODF, ODT, ODS, ODP, or {{w|OpenDocument|other types}} derived from something such as {{w|OpenOffice.org XML}}.
+
In this comic, [[Cueball]] has sent his essay to someone else (apparently a professor who was going to revise the essay before final delivery). While the essay itself was good, the professor was worried because the essay was in a .doc format, the {{w|Proprietary Software|proprietary format}} that old versions of {{w|Microsoft Word}} used [compared to the newer .docx format (circa 2013)]. The professor then advises Cueball to use a format based on open standard (one example being the .ood format used in {{w|OpenOffice}} and {{w|LibreOffice}}, both {{w|free software}} ([[http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl.html/ referring to freedom, not price]]). However, Cueball, who does not appreciate the professor's ideology, whined about how the professor is making petty fights about the details of software instead of simply bothering that the software woks (which is, in essence, a primordial purpose of software). Given that open-source software tend to lack the familiarity, features, support and reach of their proprietary variants, not working with proprietary formats in extreme cases, Cueball has *some* justification for his stance.
  
−
Cueball, who does not appreciate Stallman criticizing the file format over the actual contents of the file, accuses him of pedantically stirring up trouble instead of simply caring that the software works (which is what most regular users would be concerned about). Given that it can be a challenge to move from a familiar proprietary application to an open-source rival which may lack compatibility, features, support, and popularity, Cueball's stance is not entirely unjustified.
+
The professor brings up that he is just concerned at the current proprietary software infrastructure that forces users to use software in a specific way, penalizing them for sharing the software or even looking at the source code in order to learn how the programme works so nicely or even how to code nicely in the first place. Cueball makes a retort that the professor has [[http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html/ an arrogance that crowds out his perspective]] while claiming that the professor is {{w|Autism|autistic}}. (Autistic people do have a tendency to have intense fixations to things, even things that other people would find mundane or even odd. They also have trouble knowing the problems of the world outside of themselves, having them lack perspective of things at times. Even so, Cueball's remark suggests that he thinks that "autistic" is just another word for "retarded" which is another word for "stupid," a double-fallancy.)
  
−
Stallman tries to explain that he is just concerned about the current proprietary software infrastructure that forces users to use software in a specific way, penalizing them for sharing the software or even preventing looking at the source code in order to learn what the program actually does or how it works. Cueball, however, isn't buying it, and accuses him of having [https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html an arrogance that crowds out his perspective], while also claiming that he is {{w|Autism|autistic}}, an ableist epithet often aimed, particularly by denizens of online forums and imageboards, at people who have an intense fixation on seemingly trivial things.
+
Later, Cueball runs to the professor clamoring about Facebook's heavy policies about is complete control about the information its users submit. Since both Microsoft and Facebook have a lack of transparency about their services and take away a lot of control from the user, the professor retorts with playing "the world's tiniest open-source violin." While "playing the world's smallest violin" is a sarcastic expression that denotes that the speaker will not give pity to the recipient, the thitle text reveals that the professor is playing an ***actual*** violin.
  
−
Seven years later, Cueball runs to Stallman, having become alarmed at Facebook's immense control and dubious policies about the personal information it collects. Since this is exactly the kind of situation Stallman was warning against, he sarcastically retorts by producing "the world's tiniest open-source violin". This is a twist on "{{tvtropes|WorldsSmallestViolin|playing the world's smallest violin}}", a gesture used to convey sarcastic pity at someone else's misfortune. Interestingly, he does actually appear to possess the physical instrument itself, which is uncommon. This implies that he has been carrying around the violin for this eventuality (not unlike what [[Black Hat]] does in [[757: Toot]]), or perhaps he uses this sarcastic expression often enough to warrant it. Since the violin is so tiny, it is rendered only by a few pixels forming a line bottomed with an ovoid shape resembling the vague shape of a violin. The problem with the lack of open source and Facebook is also the subject of [[1390: Research Ethics]].
+
The title text references the following services that are compatible with the "free software" ideology:
 +
: [[http://www.creativecommons.org Creative Commons licenses]] use existing copyright law to permit someone to share a work (in this case, a song) anywhere if the sharer attributes credit to the creator of the work. There are also options for allowing modification, derivative works, and commercial usage
 +
: The "seed" to which the professor mentioned is a reference to {{w|Torrenting}}, an infrastructure that allows users to host the files others download. Essentially, the user packs a( set of) file(s) in a torrent file then "seeds" the torrent file using a programme made for torrenting (for example, {{w|uTorrent}}, the "seeder"'s computer essentially turning into a server. People who want to download the files would download the associated torrent file, use a torrenting programme, and "leech" the file. After the file(s) inside the torrent file is downloaded, the "leechers" can "seed" the file so that more people can download the file in turn. Since the user is in control of the upload and download, torrenting is an option of choice for those in support of free software.
 +
: {{w|JoinDiaspora.net}} is the central host of Diaspora, an open-source alternative to Facebook which puts the user in control of how his information is used. (There is a bit of irony here, since Cueball went to the professor due to his own problems with how Facebook handled his information.)
  
−
The title text references the following pieces of infrastructure that are compatible with the "free software" ideology:
+
{{Incomplete}}
−
* [https://www.creativecommons.org Creative Commons licenses] (CC licensed) use existing copyright law to permit someone to share a creative work anywhere so long as the sharer attributes credit to the creator of the work. The particular CC license chosen may also allow for modification, derivative works, and/or commercial usage. The fellow's phrase "you can get it" in the title text is ambiguous: is he offering to share the code for the violin, or the tune that the violin plays? But since CC licenses are not used for software, we can assume "it" refers to the tune: either an audio recording of it, or perhaps source material from which to make modified versions.
 
−
* [https://diasporafoundation.org diasporafoundation.org] (formerly joindiaspora.net, and then joindiaspora.com) is the central host of {{w|Diaspora (social network)| Diaspora*}}, an open-source alternative to Facebook which puts the user in control of how their information is used. Of course, this sort of use of Diaspora would eliminate Cueball's concern over how Facebook handled his information. A few months after this comic released, a consumer alpha version of Diaspora* was released, and, after more than a decade, an official version would be released.
 
−
* a Diaspora "seed" is a personal web server that interacts in a Diaspora "pod" of servers. It stores all of your information (such as the tune in this case) and shares it with your friends, in a way that respects your preferences around privacy, etc.
 
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
−
:2003:
+
:[A man approaches a bearded fellow.]
−
:[Cueball approaches a bearded fellow.]
+
:Man: Did you get my essay?
−
:Cueball: Did you get my essay?
+
:Bearded Fellow: Yeah, it was good! But it was a .doc; You should really use a more open--
−
:Bearded Fellow: Yeah, it was good! But it was a .doc; You should really use a more open-
+
:Man: Give it a  
−
:Cueball: Give it a ''rest'' already. Maybe we just want to live our lives and use software that ''works'', not get wrapped up in your stupid nerd turf wars.
+
:rest
−
 
+
: already. Maybe we just want to live our lives and use software that  
−
:Bearded Fellow: I just want people to care about the infrastructures we're building and who-
+
:works
−
:Cueball: No, you just want to feel smugly superior. You have no sense of perspective and are probably autistic.
+
:, not get wrapped up in your stupid nerd turf wars.
−
 
+
:
 +
:Bearded Fellow: I just want people to care about the infrastructures we're building and who--
 +
:Man: No, you just want to feel smugly superior. You have no sense of perspective and are probably autistic.
 +
:
 
:2010:
 
:2010:
−
:Cueball: Oh my God! We handed control of our social world to Facebook and they're ''DOING EVIL STUFF!''
+
:Man: Oh my God! We handed control of our social world to Facebook and they're  
−
 
+
:DOING EVIL STUFF!
 +
:
 
:Bearded Fellow: Do you see this?
 
:Bearded Fellow: Do you see this?
−
 
+
:
 
:[Inset, the bearded fellow rubs his index and middle fingers against his thumb.]
 
:[Inset, the bearded fellow rubs his index and middle fingers against his thumb.]
−
:Bearded Fellow: ''It's the world's tiniest open-source violin.''
+
:Bearded Fellow:  
−
 
+
:It's the world's tiniest open-source violin.
−
==Trivia==
 
−
In response to this comic, a [https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:3193 3D model for a tiny violin] was released as open-source files.
 
  
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
{{comic discussion}}
  
−
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
+
[[Category: Comics featuring Cueball]][[Category:Programming]][[Category:Social networking]]
−
[[Category:Comics featuring Richard Stallman]]
 
−
[[Category:Comics featuring real people]]
 
−
[[Category:Programming]]
 
−
[[Category:Social networking]]
 

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page:

Retrieved from "https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/743:_Infrastructures"