Difference between revisions of "162: Angular Momentum"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Explanation: note about not gaining time)
m (this was worded in a weirdly complex way)
 
(33 intermediate revisions by 21 users not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
 +
Every moving object, including the Earth, possesses {{w|momentum}}. The Earth has a very high momentum due to its large mass and high speed as it orbits the Sun. However, the comic refers specifically to the Earth's angular momentum generated by its rotation on its axis, which creates the day/night cycle. This momentum can change (increase, decrease, or halt) through the application of force from another object, which acts as the transfer of momentum from one object to another.
  
A '''moving object''' (like the Earth) has momentum. '''[https://www.quora.com/If-light-does-not-have-mass-then-how-does-it-have-momentum-1 Momentum]''' is the '''mass''' (size) of the object multiplied by the '''velocity''' (speed) of the moving object. So the Earth moving around the Sun has a '''very high momentum''' because the Earth has a '''large mass''' (size) and is moving at a '''high velocity''' (speed).
+
[[Megan]] is attempting to slow down the Earth's angular momentum by spinning counterclockwise (a.k.a. {{wiktionary|anticlockwise}}) and force her momentum onto the Earth, so she can have more time to spend with [[Cueball]]. The momentum she produces is minuscule relative to the Earth's. The attosecond she's gaining by spinning while being with Cueball is nothing compared with the seconds spent spinning. A Reddit user [https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/5ccbzs/comment/d9vskah calculated] the time Megan is gaining by spinning is less than the time it takes for light to travel across 5% of the diameter of an atom. Megan could gain a considerably larger (but still minuscule) amount of time [https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/4mdihu/request_if_every_single_person_in_the_world_did/d3uvmk3/ by walking to the equator]. Later, in [[442: xkcd Loves the Discovery Channel]], the same kind of spinning Megan is used in the first frame to tell that xkcd loves momentum.  {{w|Wired (magazine)|Wired}} [https://www.wired.com/2014/04/can-you-slow-down-a-day-using-angular-momentum/ calculated] how much time Megan slowed down. And finally, in ''[[xkcd: volume 0]]'', this is also calculated above the comic, giving a final value of 10<sup>-35</sup>s per turn, or 1/10000 of a quectosecond. This comic is referenced at the end of the ''[[what if? (blog)|what if?]]'' article ''{{what if|42|Longest Sunset}}''.
  
A moving object has to keep moving '''at the same velocity''' for its momentum to stay the same. The momentum of a moving object can increase, decrease, or stop via the force of another object. '''Force''' is the transfer of momentum from one object to another.
+
The title text also jokes that the amount of time Megan is gaining from spinning might also not be worth her risk of vomiting due to the dizziness.
 
 
[[Megan]] attempts to slow down the Earth's momentum, and spins counter-clockwise to force her momentum onto the Earth, so that she can spend more time with the one she loves. Of course, the few nanoseconds gained by her spinning aren't enough to give her more time with Cueball, because she spends her time spinning instead of being with Cueball.
 
 
 
The Earth has a massively high momentum, and the momentum that she produces is minuscule relative to the Earth's. And the title text implies that this isn't possible: ''While not being able to reverse time, enjoy your night time. Sunrise always comes too early.''
 
 
 
The total duration of a human lifetime is measured in physical time. The total duration of a human life is constantly depleting at a constant velocity. So even if she were able to slow down physical time, that would not increase the total duration of a human lifespan.
 
 
 
Her attempt, and her feat, of overcoming the seemingly impossible is grand; and culturally, we value this kind of high romanticism.
 
 
 
Later in [[442: xkcd Loves the Discovery Channel]] the same kind of spinning Megan is used in the first frame to tell that xkcd loves momentum.
 
 
 
Technical notes: Angular momentum [https://www.quora.com/What-is-angular-momentum-in-laymans-terms depends on the axis used for measuring angular momentum].
 
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
:[Cueball sits sideways on a bed under an open window in the corner of a room. He is looking at Megan who is spinning fast, indicated with two large circles indicating where her arms that a spread far out rotates as well as to smaller circles around her knees and feet. The bed sheets are clearly messed up as if someone has used it for other things than sleeping. It is night and dark gray outside the window and inside the room everything is also gray but lighter. Behind the spoken text the background is white, but fades to the darker gray at the edges. There is also different gray shading in different parts of the room.]
+
:[Cueball sits sideways on a bed under an open window in the corner of a room. He is looking at Megan, who is spinning fast, indicated with two large circles indicating where her arms that are spread far out rotate, as well as two smaller circles around her knees and feet. The bed sheets are clearly messed up, as if someone has used it for activities other than sleeping. It is night and dark gray outside the window, and inside the room everything is also gray but lighter. Behind the spoken text, the background is white, but fades to the darker gray at the edges. There is also different gray shading in different parts of the room.]
 
:Cueball: What are you doing?
 
:Cueball: What are you doing?
 
:Megan: Spinning counterclockwise
 
:Megan: Spinning counterclockwise
Line 36: Line 25:
  
 
==Trivia==
 
==Trivia==
*This is one of the [[:Category:Footer comics|five footer comics]] linked at the bottom part of the {{xkcd}} website.
+
* This is one of the six [[Footer comics|footer comics]] featured in the bottom segment of [https://xkcd.com xkcd.com].
 +
* This comic used to be [https://web.archive.org/web/20220125023401/https://store.xkcd.com/products/signed-prints available as a signed print] in the xkcd store before it was [[Store|shut down]].
  
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
{{comic discussion}}
 +
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Megan]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Megan]]
Line 44: Line 35:
 
[[Category:Romance]]
 
[[Category:Romance]]
 
[[Category:Footer comics]]
 
[[Category:Footer comics]]
 +
[[Category:Comics with xkcd store products]]

Latest revision as of 15:23, 22 October 2024

Angular Momentum
With reasonable assumptions about latitude and body shape, how much time might she gain them? Note: whatever the answer, sunrise always comes too soon. (Also, is it worth it if she throws up?)
Title text: With reasonable assumptions about latitude and body shape, how much time might she gain them? Note: whatever the answer, sunrise always comes too soon. (Also, is it worth it if she throws up?)

Explanation[edit]

Every moving object, including the Earth, possesses momentum. The Earth has a very high momentum due to its large mass and high speed as it orbits the Sun. However, the comic refers specifically to the Earth's angular momentum generated by its rotation on its axis, which creates the day/night cycle. This momentum can change (increase, decrease, or halt) through the application of force from another object, which acts as the transfer of momentum from one object to another.

Megan is attempting to slow down the Earth's angular momentum by spinning counterclockwise (a.k.a. anticlockwise) and force her momentum onto the Earth, so she can have more time to spend with Cueball. The momentum she produces is minuscule relative to the Earth's. The attosecond she's gaining by spinning while being with Cueball is nothing compared with the seconds spent spinning. A Reddit user calculated the time Megan is gaining by spinning is less than the time it takes for light to travel across 5% of the diameter of an atom. Megan could gain a considerably larger (but still minuscule) amount of time by walking to the equator. Later, in 442: xkcd Loves the Discovery Channel, the same kind of spinning Megan is used in the first frame to tell that xkcd loves momentum. Wired calculated how much time Megan slowed down. And finally, in xkcd: volume 0, this is also calculated above the comic, giving a final value of 10-35s per turn, or 1/10000 of a quectosecond. This comic is referenced at the end of the what if? article Longest Sunset.

The title text also jokes that the amount of time Megan is gaining from spinning might also not be worth her risk of vomiting due to the dizziness.

Transcript[edit]

[Cueball sits sideways on a bed under an open window in the corner of a room. He is looking at Megan, who is spinning fast, indicated with two large circles indicating where her arms that are spread far out rotate, as well as two smaller circles around her knees and feet. The bed sheets are clearly messed up, as if someone has used it for activities other than sleeping. It is night and dark gray outside the window, and inside the room everything is also gray but lighter. Behind the spoken text, the background is white, but fades to the darker gray at the edges. There is also different gray shading in different parts of the room.]
Cueball: What are you doing?
Megan: Spinning counterclockwise
Megan: Each turn robs the planet of angular momentum
Megan: Slowing its spin the tiniest bit
Megan: Lengthening the night, pushing back the dawn
Megan: Giving me a little more time here
Megan: With you

Trivia[edit]


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

The issue date is not given, as i don't have a clue about it. Could someone fix this? Rikthoff (talk) 19:30, 3 August 2012 (EDT)

When the page was updated to the new comic template by User:Bpothier he fixed the date. lcarsos (talk) 20:48, 28 August 2012 (UTC)

That actually is a neat physics puzzle, which has probably (i.e. certainly) been addressed somewhere on the net. I may incorporate that some day. --Quicksilver (talk) 05:58, 24 August 2013 (UTC)

I tried to calculate the change in Earth's period, assuming that she was standing in the north pole (latitude = 90º N), where her spinning would have more effect. I either did something wrong, or my TI-84 Plus is not capable of detecting the very small effect her spinning would have on the Earth's rotation. I assumed the Earth had a period of exactly 24 hours, and got the same value to the second, even if she was spinning at 1000 turns per second, which seems like a lot.

Here's the formula:

L_Earth_i = L_Earth_f + L_spinner <=>

I_Earth * (2*PI)/T_Earth_i = I_Earth * (2*PI)/T_Earth_f + I_spinner* (2*PI) * f_spinner <=>

(1/T_Earth_f) = (1/T_Earth_i) - (I_spinner/I_Earth)*f_spinner <=>

T_Earth_f = 1/((1/T_Earth_i) - (I_spinner/I_Earth)*f_spinner)


Where the variables have names in the format:

[variable name]_[object it refers to]_[situation (i or f stand for initial and final)]


L = Angular Moment

I = Moment of Inertia

T = Period of rotation about one's axis

f = frequency


I used as values:

T_Earth_i = 86400 seconds (24 hours exactly)

I_spinner = 62,04 Kg.m^2 (Found on Wolfram|Alpha, for a 62Kg adult human being)

I_Earth = 8,03e+37 Kg.m^2 (http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/physics/MomentofInertiaEarth.html)

f_spinner = the frequency of the woman's spinning in complete turns per second. 2.82.142.28 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

Taking that a bit further, the relative decrease is:
  (T_Earth_f - T_Earth_i)/T_Earth_i = 1 / (I_Earth/(I_spinner*T_Earth_i*f_spinner) - 1)
     = 1 / ( 1.5 e+28 - 1) ~= 67 e-30
Fwiw, the absolute value is 5.767 yocto-seconds. If the entire world population would spin at that 1000 turns per second (and at favourable locations as in your assumptions), the effect will still be a measly 0.041 pico-seconds. So T_Earth_f = 86 399.999 999 999 999 958 ... But the TI-84 only has about 14 digits precision, i believe, so even that won't show up. -- 173.245.51.210 22:46, 30 October 2013 (UTC)

Is it possible for someone to write an equation that factors in latitude (and, if relevant, longitude) that we could plug our locations into and get a value from? That would be awesome. Thanks. 108.162.250.208 02:48, 23 February 2014 (UTC)

The visual style and theme of this comic is clearly referencing the 'Spinning Ballerina Optical Illusion' (evidenced by the grey-to-white gradient 'glow', as well as her arm and leg positions). 108.162.249.231 03:03, 30 September 2014 (UTC)

The 'Spinning Ballerina' optical illusion does not apply here, Megan clearly stated that she was spinning 'counterclockwise' and due to the fact that she is drawn with hair (not a silhouette) lets you know where she is facing. Therefore the bent leg on the right of the image is her left leg. Plus there aren't many ways to draw a stick figure 'spinning'. Now if it were Cueball doing the spinning THEN I would agree with you because there would not be a reference point to make any type of judgement and therefore a point could be made that could be a reference Randall was trying to make. Nexxuz (talk)

The momentum of Megan is in fact one order of magnitude smaller than what appeared in above calculation, so the dilation effect is still smaller.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=moment+of+inertia+of+solid+cylinder+for+a%3D0.25m%2Cmass%3D62kg 173.245.50.90 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

After reading this comics, I got one question. I thought one cant change the total momentum of a closed system of bodies. I mean, from the point of view outside of Earth, she would be spinning, but the momentum which Megan, or whatever her name is, gained in counter-clock-wise direction would also show in Earth clock-wise direction (positively). Basically I am referring to a situation of a man walking on a boat. (the boat moves, the man moves, but the position man-lake is still the same). So I figured it should be in this way. She spins, yeah, but the Earth now spins in opposite direction a little more, so in the end it is still the same. Now, she could totally delay time by approaching light speed as she spins, which would be weird though as her head (closer to rotational axis) would have smaller velocity than her hands (and thus faster time flow) resulting in, hmm, her body parts getting lost in time? 141.101.97.220 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

The total angular momentum cannot be altered from inside the closed system, but it can be distributed differently among the different bodies. This means that the angular speed of the Earth will be actually reduced, but only of a fixed value (proportional to Megan's angular speed) and only as long as Megan spins. It will revert to its original value when Megan stops spinning. Alexxx (talk) 23:24, 6 December 2015 (UTC) 141.101.104.8 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)
The total angular momentum is not changed, but while Megan is spinning the Earth is rotating slower. When she stops spinning, the Earth resumes it's previous spin rate, but not in the same position, and therefore dawn comes later.
You can compare with the man on the boat situation. If a man walks forward in the boat, the boat moves backward; when the man stops, the boat stops, too, but it is not in the same position it was at the beginning.--Pere prlpz (talk) 17:29, 17 December 2015 (UTC)


Wouldn't she have to be spinning at the Geographic North Pole to have any effect? As it is she's spinning with her axis of rotation at some angle (depending on latitude ) to the Earth's axis of rotation so she's not having much of any effect at all. 173.245.54.190 10:15, 2 April 2015 (UTC)

The effect is stronger in the North Pole, but in temperate latidudes it's still strong. In fact, it's proportional to sine of latitude. Therefore, if the comic is set in Boston (where I think Randall lives), it's just a 33% weaker than in the Pole (sin(42º)=0,67).
Furthermore, out of the Pole, Megan's spin will slightly change the Earth's rotation axis, but this will have little effect on the time of dawn.--Pere prlpz (talk) 17:22, 17 December 2015 (UTC)

Is she spinning counter clockwise when viewed from below or above? (Up spin or down spin?) 108.162.219.188 06:35, 24 June 2015 (UTC)

I'm guessing she's spinning counter-clockwise as viewed from above. (I think that would be up-spin, by the right-hand-rule, if that's what you mean.) Assuming she's in the northern hemisphere, if I understand this correctly, as she pushes herself counter-clockwise, her feet exert clockwise torque on the earth, opposing the earth's counter-clockwise rotation on its axis (as viewed from above the north pole), slowing the earth's rotation slightly, thus "lengthening the night, pushing back the dawn"...by a mere 5.767×10-24 seconds (according to earlier comments) — I think that's the joke in this comic. -- Yfmcpxpj (talk) 16:24, 6 December 2019 (UTC)

I'm no physicist, but the opening paragraph of the explanation seems to be about linear momentum, p=mv, whereas I think the comic might be referring to angular momentum, L=Iω. I wonder if Megan isn't trying to slow the earth's speed around the sun, nor trying to "slow down the rate of time", but is actually trying to "lengthen the night, push back the dawn" (because their time together will end at dawn), by slowing down the earth's rotation on its own axis? -- Yfmcpxpj (talk) 16:24, 6 December 2019 (UTC)