| Latest revision |
Your text |
| Line 4: |
Line 4: |
| | | title = First Post | | | title = First Post |
| | | image = first_post.png | | | image = first_post.png |
| | + | | imagesize = |
| | | titletext = 'Nuh-uh! We let users vote on comments and display them by number of votes. Everyone knows that makes it impossible for a few persistent voices to dominate the discussion.' | | | titletext = 'Nuh-uh! We let users vote on comments and display them by number of votes. Everyone knows that makes it impossible for a few persistent voices to dominate the discussion.' |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | | |
| − | ==Explanation== | + | '''Bold text'''==Explanation== |
| − | Many news websites allow users to post comments on an article. The intention is that users can debate the stance(s) or implication(s) made by the article. On most sites, comments are displayed in chronological order. This puts the oldest comments at the top and newest at the bottom.
| + | {{incomplete|The proper interpretation of this comic, or whether there even is one, remains an open question.}} |
| | + | This comic looks at most every comment section in the history of the internet. The comic itself takes on sites that display comments in the order received. Lots of major newspapers do this and it helps only in showing what sort of lunatics read and comment on newspaper articles. Most of the time, the comments section is not worth reading. |
| | | | |
| − | There are many pitfalls to allowing comments, but this comic refers to one in particular: most users are too busy to read more than just the top few comments. Therefore, if you were able to control the content of those comments, your opinions would be the ones that the majority of users read. If you pay people to do nothing but read the site, you ensure that they will be the first ones to see the article and that their comments (that you pay them to write) will be at the top of the page. In this scenario, the comments being posted appear to convey a particular political belief. The advantage of this is, according to [[Randall]], that it would be much cheaper to employ a college student to perform that task than pay a website for an advertisement. Also, the fact that it is a comment posted by another reader would make it seem as though the opinion was coming from the general population and not a politician or company, as an advertisement would imply. And $20/hour was (and as of this writing still is) significantly higher than the {{w|minimum wage}}, so you'd have no trouble finding willing participants among college students (who are often broke).
| + | However, the title text takes on sites like {{w|Reddit}} [http://www.reddit.com/] that sort the comments by number of votes. The most popular comments go right to the top. This is certainly an improvement, but [[Randall]] uses this quotation in the title text sarcastically. In that, he doesn't believe it, in fact he believes just the opposite. |
| − | | |
| − | This comic is a continuation of [[937: TornadoGuard]] which stated "the problem with star ratings". Apparently, every possible comment ordering policy has its own problems.
| |
| − | | |
| − | The title text refers to systems like {{w|Reddit|Reddit's}} {{w|conversation threading}} which allow users to vote comments up or down and to sort them by the resulting "karma score" (total up-votes minus total down-votes). The hired students could easily be assigned to also upvote each other’s posts. Even without collusion, the same problem persists to some extent: after a few comments are posted and some votes are cast, the handful of comments having received the highest scores among the first dozen of so will receive far better chances at being seen and voted on than comments posted later, and will solidify their places in a positive {{w|Feedback|feedback}} loop. In this way, a few persistent voices can still dominate the discussion, contrary to the claim in the title text, thus creating irony.
| |
| − | | |
| − | The comic's title refers to a once-common form of online posturing where the first user to see the article will comment "First post" or even just "First". The intent is that everyone else see that they were there first and, therefore, must be somehow better than you. This is referred to in both [[269: TCMP]] and [[1258: First]]. | |
| − | | |
| − | Since this comic's publication several news sites have elected to remove all comments, in part to prevent [https://www.niemanlab.org/2015/09/what-happened-after-7-news-sites-got-rid-of-reader-comments/ a few voices] [https://www.npr.org/sections/publiceditor/2016/08/17/489516952/npr-website-to-get-rid-of-comments?t=1568619071215 dominating the conversation].
| |
| − | | |
| − | In [[2159: Comments]], this strip is mentioned, along with the text "This dynamic is so easily manipulated and it freaks me out." | |
| | | | |
| | ==Transcript== | | ==Transcript== |
| − | :[Single panel showing a bar graph with two gray vertical bars, a dollar amount above each bar, the vertical axis on the left side with tick marks every $250,000, and the horizontal axis at the bottom with a descriptive label below each bar under the axis. The first bar is much taller than the second.] | + | :[A bar graph with two bars. The first bar is much taller than the second. It is marked '$1,500,000', and below the x-axis, is labelled "Cost to buy an ad on every story on a major news site every day until the election. The second bar is much shorter, marked "$200,000', and labelled "Cost to pay five college students $20/hour to camp the site 24/7 and post the first few comments the moment a story goes up, giving you the last word in every article and creating an impression of peer consensus.] |
| − | | + | :The problem with posting comments in the order they're submitted. |
| − | :[First bar:]
| |
| − | :Amount: $1,500,000
| |
| − | :Label: Cost to buy an ad on every story on a major news site every day until the election
| |
| − | | |
| − | :[Second bar:]
| |
| − | :Amount: $200,000
| |
| − | :Label: Cost to pay five college students $20/hour to camp the site 24/7 and post the first few comments the moment a story goes up, giving you the last word in every article and creating an impression of peer consensus
| |
| − | | |
| − | :[Caption below the panel:]
| |
| − | :The problem with posting comments in the order they're submitted | |
| | | | |
| | {{comic discussion}} | | {{comic discussion}} |
| − | | + | [[Category:Charts]] |
| − | [[Category:Bar charts]] | |
| − | [[Category:Politics]]
| |
