Difference between revisions of "718: The Flake Equation"
(→Explanation) |
Paravellex (talk | contribs) (→Explanation: There are no clear "likely values" for an equation like this; any guess would be a WAG. Only change needed was origin of term "Flake".) |
||
(5 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
==Explanation== | ==Explanation== | ||
− | {{ | + | The Flake equation is a parody of the {{w|Drake equation}} , which is an estimate the number of detectable extraterrestrial civilizations in our galaxy. The Flake equation, however, provides an estimate about how many stories ''about'' aliens are likely to exist. It does so in similar manner: by multiplying number of stars by consecutive probabilities of the star having certain characteristics making detectable life possible. Just like the Drake equation, exact numbers are unknown, but can be estimated, and the equation shows the guesses about the values. |
− | The Flake | + | The word "Flake" is informally used to describe a crazy person, such as someone who would imagine an alien encounter. |
+ | |||
+ | ===Explanations of values=== | ||
+ | {| class="wikitable" | ||
+ | !Symbol | ||
+ | !Assumed value | ||
+ | !Explanation | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |||
+ | |W<sub>P</sub> | ||
+ | |7,000,000,000 | ||
+ | |World population at the time of the creation of the comic, taken as a starting value. | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |(C<sub>R</sub> + M<sub>i</sub>) | ||
+ | |1/10,000 + 1/10,000 | ||
+ | |Fraction of people who would believe they had been visited by aliens. This is assumed to be people who are crazy, want to feel special, or misinterpret physical phenomena as alien sightings. It is assumed that a total of one in 10,000 people to at least one of the first two of these groups and another one in 10,000 belong to the final group, for a total of one in 5000 belonging to one of these three groups. Multiplied by the world population we get the number of people who believe to have been visited by aliens | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |T<sub>K</sub> | ||
+ | |1/10 | ||
+ | |The fraction of those people, who believe to have experienced an alien sighting, that tell others about their experience. Multiplying with the previous values we get the number of people who believe to have experienced an alien sighting, and tell others about it. | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |F<sub>0</sub> | ||
+ | |10 | ||
+ | |Average number of people they tell about their "sightings". Multiplying with the previous values we get the amount of people this is the amount of people who hear about the alien sighting from the "primary source". | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |F<sub>1</sub> | ||
+ | |10 | ||
+ | |Average number of people that they decide to tell about the "firsthand" account. Multiplying with the previous values we get the amount of people who hear a second-hand account. | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |D<sub>T</sub> | ||
+ | |9/10 | ||
+ | |The probability that the details will be slightly adjusted during the retelling process, making the account believable. The total is now the amount of believable alien sighting stories. | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | |A<sub>U</sub> | ||
+ | |1/100 | ||
+ | |The proportion of people who have the willingness and ability to share this story with the with a broad audience. The total is now the amount of believable alien sightings that are published to a wider audience. | ||
+ | |} | ||
+ | |||
+ | The final results tells us that there should be about 100 000 stories about aliens that have reliable explanation. The data is obviously highly uncertain, and as with the Drake Equation, you can plug in your own numbers, but if you keep your guesses realistic, you will most likely get a very large number. This convinces the reader that the fact that there are many stories about aliens does not necessarily means that many people actually met aliens. | ||
The title text refers to Fermi's Lack-of-a-Paradox as a parody of the {{w|Fermi paradox}}: The contradiction between the high estimated probable existence of extraterrestrial civilizations and the lack of establishing contact to such civilizations by humans. | The title text refers to Fermi's Lack-of-a-Paradox as a parody of the {{w|Fermi paradox}}: The contradiction between the high estimated probable existence of extraterrestrial civilizations and the lack of establishing contact to such civilizations by humans. |
Revision as of 07:38, 12 June 2017
Explanation
The Flake equation is a parody of the Drake equation , which is an estimate the number of detectable extraterrestrial civilizations in our galaxy. The Flake equation, however, provides an estimate about how many stories about aliens are likely to exist. It does so in similar manner: by multiplying number of stars by consecutive probabilities of the star having certain characteristics making detectable life possible. Just like the Drake equation, exact numbers are unknown, but can be estimated, and the equation shows the guesses about the values.
The word "Flake" is informally used to describe a crazy person, such as someone who would imagine an alien encounter.
Explanations of values
Symbol | Assumed value | Explanation |
---|---|---|
W_{P} | 7,000,000,000 | World population at the time of the creation of the comic, taken as a starting value. |
(C_{R} + M_{i}) | 1/10,000 + 1/10,000 | Fraction of people who would believe they had been visited by aliens. This is assumed to be people who are crazy, want to feel special, or misinterpret physical phenomena as alien sightings. It is assumed that a total of one in 10,000 people to at least one of the first two of these groups and another one in 10,000 belong to the final group, for a total of one in 5000 belonging to one of these three groups. Multiplied by the world population we get the number of people who believe to have been visited by aliens |
T_{K} | 1/10 | The fraction of those people, who believe to have experienced an alien sighting, that tell others about their experience. Multiplying with the previous values we get the number of people who believe to have experienced an alien sighting, and tell others about it. |
F_{0} | 10 | Average number of people they tell about their "sightings". Multiplying with the previous values we get the amount of people this is the amount of people who hear about the alien sighting from the "primary source". |
F_{1} | 10 | Average number of people that they decide to tell about the "firsthand" account. Multiplying with the previous values we get the amount of people who hear a second-hand account. |
D_{T} | 9/10 | The probability that the details will be slightly adjusted during the retelling process, making the account believable. The total is now the amount of believable alien sighting stories. |
A_{U} | 1/100 | The proportion of people who have the willingness and ability to share this story with the with a broad audience. The total is now the amount of believable alien sightings that are published to a wider audience. |
The final results tells us that there should be about 100 000 stories about aliens that have reliable explanation. The data is obviously highly uncertain, and as with the Drake Equation, you can plug in your own numbers, but if you keep your guesses realistic, you will most likely get a very large number. This convinces the reader that the fact that there are many stories about aliens does not necessarily means that many people actually met aliens.
The title text refers to Fermi's Lack-of-a-Paradox as a parody of the Fermi paradox: The contradiction between the high estimated probable existence of extraterrestrial civilizations and the lack of establishing contact to such civilizations by humans.
Another comic parodying this equation is 384: The Drake Equation. The credibility of paranormal reports in general is revisited in 1235: Settled, which posits that if such phenomena were real they should have been unambiguously captured on camera by now.
Transcript
- The Flake Equation:
- P = W_{P} × (C_{R} + M_{I}) × T_{K} × F_{0} × F_{1} × D_{T} × A_{U} ≈ 100,000
- Where:
- W_{P} = World Population (7,000,000,000)
- C_{R} = Fraction of people who imagine an alien encounter because they're crazy or want to feel special (1/10,000)
- M_{I} = Fraction of people who misinterpret a physical or physiological experience as an alien sighting (1/10,000)
- T_{K} = Probability that they'll tell someone (1/10)
- F_{0} = Average number of people they tell (10)
- F_{1} = Average number of people each friend tells this "firsthand" account (10)
- D_{T} = Probability that any details not fitting the narrative will be revised or forgotten in retelling (9/10)
- A_{U} = Fraction of people with the means and motivation to share the story with a wider audience (blogs, forums, reporters) (1/100)
- Even with conservative guesses for the values of the variables, this suggests there must be a huge number of credible-sounding alien sightings out there, available to anyone who wants to believe!
Discussion
Anybody notice that the real product of the numbers he gives is 6.3 (10), not 100,000? 02:32, 16 April 2017 (UTC)
No, it's not - you've multiplied Cr and Mx when you should have added them. The real product is 126,000 = 100,000. 162.158.69.51
There was a later comic about our capabilities' precluding of UFO sightings and such. I may find it at some point. --Quicksilver (talk) 02:51, 20 August 2013 (UTC)
Settled
googlesearch=site:explainxkcd.com ufo
http://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1235:_Settled
Kevin McCready (talk) 13:25, 10 May 2014 (UTC)
Is there any significance to the word "flake"? Urban Dictionary says it stands for "unreliable person", but certainly not in context of alien sightings. --162.158.90.217 13:34, 26 August 2015 (UTC)
It's a portmanteau of "Drake" and "Fake". --172.68.10.94 10:58, 4 February 2017 (UTC)