Editing 1680: Black Hole

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
[[Cueball]] is curious as to why [[Black Hat]] has a miniature {{w|black hole}} on his table; Black Hat responds that it "really brings the room together", making a pun on both the black hole aesthetically completing the look of the room as well as it literally "bringing the room together" through its gravitational pull. Evidently the black hole is massive enough to bring the room together optically into visible {{w|Einstein ring}}s by {{w|gravitational lensing}}.
+
{{incomplete|More details... What would happen if a black hole like this was in a living room... It's not clear what exactly in the comic is a reference to the Big Lebowski movie. This needs clarification}}
 +
[[Cueball]] is curious as to why [[Black Hat]] has a miniature {{w|black hole}} on his table; Black Hat responds that it "really brings the room together", making a pun on both the black hole aesthetically completing the room as well as it literally "bringing the room together" through its gravitational pull. Evidently the black hole is massive enough to bring the room together optically into visible {{w|Einstein ring}}s by {{w|gravitational lensing}}.
  
The title text makes a cultural reference to a well-known song lyric from the 2003 song "{{w|Milkshake (song)|Milkshake}}" by {{w|Kelis}}, where the singer brags of her milkshake being so popular that it "brings all the boys to the yard" (what "milkshake" is a metaphor for has never been specified). But in this case, since {{w|gravity}} does not discriminate between which things it pulls,{{Citation needed}} it brings "the boys, and everything else" to Black Hat's yard - and unlike with the milkshake, not by choice. If it wasn't for the house walls (which somehow resist collapsing into the black hole), they wouldn't remain in the yard but would come into the room with the black hole, and then into the black hole itself.
+
The comic references 'The Dude's' rug in the film "{{w|The Big Lebowski}}", whilst the title text makes a more contemporary cultural reference to a well-known song lyric from the song "{{w|Milkshake (song)|Milkshake}}" by {{w|Kelis}}; however, in this case, since {{w|gravity}} does not discriminate between which things it will attract{{Citation needed}}, it brings "the boys, and everything else", to Black Hat's yard.
  
As depicted, the black hole is inconsistent with several aspects of physics:
+
[[Randall]] describes a similar scenario in the "Neutron Bullet" chapter of the [http://whatif.xkcd.com/book/ what if? book], and a black hole of similar dimensions in the [[what if?]] ''{{what if|129|Black Hole Moon}}''.
*This black hole appears to be about the size of a marble. A marble size is approximately Earth's {{w|Schwarzschild radius}}, suggesting this black hole to have Earth-like mass. (Since Cueball and Black Hat are able to stand upright, it suggests the gravitational pull is a fraction of Earth's, Making the black hole's mass also a fraction of Earth's. The black hole may appear visibly larger due to having a visible accretion disc.) See link below.
+
 
*A large (and {{w|Earth|massive}}) black hole would bring the room together, in less time than Cueball could converse with Black Hat. The gravitational acceleration of an Earth mass black hole would be of the order of 10<sup>13</sup> m/s^2, and the tidal forces (the difference between the gravity at two points) only an order of magnitude less than that. Cueball and Black Hat would be {{w|spaghettification|spaghettified}} and fall towards the Black hole in a few nanoseconds. For an observer at a safe distance from the room, {{w|time dilation}} would appear to prolong the duration that the room's contents formed a messy {{w|accretion disc}} slightly larger than the black hole. (See link below)
+
As depicted, the black hole is inconsistent with some aspect of physics:
*A black hole with the mass of the Empire State Building would have gravitational acceleration of much less than 0.01 m/s^2, and consequently insignificant tidal forces.  However, unlike the scenario in "Neutron Bullet", it would emit {{w|Hawking radiation}} powerful enough to tear the room apart.
+
* A large black hole would bring the room together... in less time than Cueball could converse with Black Hat.
*An uncharged black hole would fall through the coffee table and burrow to Earth's core. Again depending on the mass. If it was an Earth mass black hole Earth would move "up" to the black hole as much as the black hole would move "down" into Earth. See link below
+
* A small black hole could have {{w|tidal force}}s weak enough to permit Cueball to stand near it.  However, unlike the scenario in "Neutron Bullet", it would emit {{w|Hawking radiation}} powerful enough to tear the room apart.
*See [http://www.kickassfacts.com/what-if-a-black-hole-the-size-of-a-coin-suddenly-appears-on-earth/ What if a black hole the size of a coin suddenly appears on earth] for some explanation along the lines of the problems mentioned above.
+
* A neutrally charged black hole would fall through the coffee table and burrow to Earth's core.
**See this animation of the answer to that question here: [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nHBGFKLHZQ Kurzgesagt's video].
 
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
 +
 
:[Cueball is standing near a coffee table as Black Hat approaches. They are presumably in Black Hat's living room. The coffee table has a miniature black hole on top of it, resting on a small pedestal.]
 
:[Cueball is standing near a coffee table as Black Hat approaches. They are presumably in Black Hat's living room. The coffee table has a miniature black hole on top of it, resting on a small pedestal.]
 
:Cueball: Why do you have a miniature black hole on your coffee table?
 
:Cueball: Why do you have a miniature black hole on your coffee table?
 
:Black Hat: It really brings the room together.
 
:Black Hat: It really brings the room together.
  
==Trivia==
+
{{comic discussion}}
*The phrase that something "brings the room together" is also a famous line in the cult film {{w|The Big Lebowski}}, where the anti-hero, the Dude, laments the theft of a rug that "really brought the room together".
 
*[[Randall]] describes a similar scenario in the "Neutron Bullet" chapter of the ''[[What If? (book)|What If?]]'' book, and a black hole of similar dimensions in the ''[[what if? (blog)|what if?]]'' article ''{{what if|129|Black Hole Moon}}''.
 
  
{{comic discussion}}
 
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Black Hat]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Black Hat]]

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)