Editing 2123: Meta Collecting

{{comic
| number    = 2123
| date      = March 13, 2019
| title     = Meta Collecting
| image     = meta_collecting.png
| titletext = I'm trying to get the page locked because some jerk keeps adding "Yachts".
}}

==Explanation==
{{incomplete|Created by a YACHT. Please mention here why this explanation isn't complete. Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}}

This is another comic in the "[[:Category:My Hobby|My Hobby]]" series.

Many people's hobbies involve {{w|collecting}} many items of the same category: Post stamps, collectable cards, painted dolls, wine, and so on. Just about anything can be collected, however, some things are collected much more often than others. Wikipedia has a page listing the most popular categories of such {{w|collectable}} items.

In Randall's usual style of going meta with everything, he decided to start a meta-collection—a collection of examples of different things that people can collect. He uses Wikipedia's {{w|list of collectables}} for reference. In the comic, [[Cueball]] is showing to his friend his collection of various items that have nothing in common except that they're all popular collectibles.  So while most people try to collect everything in one narrow category of collectibles, Cueball's collection will only be complete if he can get one item from each of the list of collectible items as cataloged by Wikipedia's list, so he has a collection of representative elements from all collections.

List of Items on the Shelf
{| class="wikitable"
!Item Location
!Description
|-
|Top Shelf, Left
|Possibly an Urn or cookie jar.
|-
|Top Shelf, Middle
|??
|-
|Top Shelf, Right
|Model Boat
|-
|Middle Shelf, Left
|
|-
|Middle Shelf, Center
(large round object)
|Vinyl Record
|-
|Bottom Shelf, Left
|Humanoid Figurine or Action Figure
|-
|Bottom, Second to Left
|Martini Glass
|-
|Bottom, Center
|Teapot
|-
|Bottom, Center Right
|Salt and Pepper shaker or Chess Piece
|-
|Bottom, Right
|??
|}


In the title text, Randall complains about a wiki editor who keeps adding {{w|yacht}}s to the list of collectables, probably because it would force him to buy a yacht if he ever wanted to complete his collection of collectables. Yachts are traditionally considered immensely expensive and the vast majority of people own zero yachts, let alone a collection of them. Note that Randall does not specify how he is trying to get the page locked, and the comic itself might be a rather meta way of doing so: xkcd fans have a history of making lots of edits to Wikipedia articles Randall mentions, resulting in them being protected or locked. The article has in fact been edited and reverted about 50 times by these fans over the course of a single day and was put in temporary protected-status on March 14th, 2019. Protection will end on March 17th, 2019 provided that no other vandalism occurs afterwards.   The first addition of Yachts to this page was by a user named {{w|Special:Contributions/Xkcd2123|Xkcd2123}}, but it is unlikely that this user is Randall.

==Transcript==

:[The comic depicts Cueball reading from a list to White Hat, standing next to a case filled with collectables including an urn, a model ship, a compact disc, a vinyl record, a doll or figurine, a martini glass, and a teapot.]
:Today we're looking for a lunchbox, a snow globe, a Maytag dryer, a Harley Davidson, and a stamp.

:[Caption below the frame:]
:My hobby: Collecting one item from every category listed on Wikipedia's "List of collectables."

==Trivia==

As of 13 March 2019 at 6:44 PM ET, there ''was'' a debate on the Wikipedia [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_collectables#May_consider_a_temporary_editing_protection talk] tab about locking this page.
This has now been upheld, and the page was temporarily locked.

A previous comic, [[739: Malamanteau]], also caused a similar situation on Wikipedia, with many xkcd fans attempting to create the fictional page. The page has been turned into a redirect to the Wikipedia page for xkcd.

{{comic discussion}}

[[Category:My Hobby]]
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
[[Category:Comics featuring White Hat]]
[[Category:Wikipedia]]
@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 ==Explanation==
+{{incomplete|Created by a YACHT. Please mention here why this explanation isn't complete. Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}}
 This is another comic in the "[[:Category:My Hobby|My Hobby]]" series.
-Many people's hobbies involve {{w|collecting}} many items of the same category: Post stamps, collectible cards, painted dolls, wine, and so on. Just about anything can be collected, however, some things are collected much more often than others. Wikipedia has a page listing the most popular categories of such {{w|collectible}} items.
+Many people's hobbies involve {{w|collecting}} many items of the same category: Post stamps, collectable cards, painted dolls, wine, and so on. Just about anything can be collected, however, some things are collected much more often than others. Wikipedia has a page listing the most popular categories of such {{w|collectable}} items.
-In Randall's usual style of going meta with everything, he decided to start a meta-collection—a collection of examples of different things that people can collect. He uses Wikipedia's {{w|list of collectibles}} for reference. In the comic, [[Cueball]] is showing to his friend his collection of various items that have nothing in common except that they're all popular collectibles. So while most people try to collect everything in one narrow category of collectibles, Cueball's collection will only be complete if he can get one item from each of the list of collectible items as cataloged by Wikipedia's list, so he has a collection of representative elements from all collections.
+In Randall's usual style of going meta with everything, he decided to start a meta-collection—a collection of examples of different things that people can collect. He uses Wikipedia's {{w|list of collectables}} for reference. In the comic, [[Cueball]] is showing to his friend his collection of various items that have nothing in common except that they're all popular collectibles.  So while most people try to collect everything in one narrow category of collectibles, Cueball's collection will only be complete if he can get one item from each of the list of collectible items as cataloged by Wikipedia's list, so he has a collection of representative elements from all collections.
-In the title text, Randall complains about a Wikipedia editor who keeps adding {{w|yacht}}s to the list of collectibles, probably because it would force him to buy a yacht if he ever wanted to complete his collection of collectibles. Yachts are traditionally considered immensely expensive and the vast majority of people own zero yachts, let alone a collection of them.{{Citation needed}} Note that Randall does not specify how he is trying to get the page locked, and the comic itself might be a rather meta way of doing so: xkcd fans have a history of making lots of edits to Wikipedia articles Randall mentions, resulting in them being protected or locked. The article has in fact been edited and reverted about 50 times by these fans over the course of a single day and was {{w|special:redirect/logid/97716186|temporarily protected}} on March 14th, 2019, which expired three days later. The first addition of Yachts to this page was by a user named {{w|Special:Contributions/Xkcd2123|Xkcd2123}}, but it is unlikely that this user is Randall.
-===List of Items on the Shelf===
-Items are numbered on each shelf from left.
+List of Items on the Shelf
 {| class="wikitable"
 !Item Location
 !Description
 |-
-|Top Shelf, First Item
+|Top Shelf, Left
 |Possibly an Urn or cookie jar.
 |-
-|Top Shelf, Second Item
+|Top Shelf, Middle
-|Possibly a candle
+|??
 |-
-|Top Shelf, Third Item
+|Top Shelf, Right
 |Model Boat
 |-
-|Middle Shelf, First Item
+|Middle Shelf, Left
-|Possibly a book
+|
 |-
-|Middle Shelf, Second Item
+|Middle Shelf, Center
-|Rock or tooth
+(large round object)
+|Vinyl Record
 |-
-|Middle Shelf, Third Item
+|Bottom Shelf, Left
-|Compact disc in case
-|-
-|Middle Shelf, Fourth Item
-|A record, probably vinyl but could possibly be shellac as shellac "78s" are popular collectors items.
-|-
-|Middle Shelf, Fifth Item
-|Possibly a card
-|-
-|Middle Shelf, Sixth Item
-|Possibly a pin-back button
-|-
-|Bottom Shelf, First Item
 |Humanoid Figurine or Action Figure
 |-
-|Bottom Shelf, Second Item
+|Bottom, Second to Left
 |Martini Glass
 |-
-|Bottom Shelf, Third Item
+|Bottom, Center
 |Teapot
 |-
-|Bottom Shelf, Fourth Item
+|Bottom, Center Right
-|Salt/Pepper shaker or Chess Piece
+|Salt and Pepper shaker or Chess Piece
 |-
-|Bottom Shelf, Fifth Item
+|Bottom, Right
-|Sickle
+|??
 |}
+In the title text, Randall complains about a wiki editor who keeps adding {{w|yacht}}s to the list of collectables, probably because it would force him to buy a yacht if he ever wanted to complete his collection of collectables. Yachts are traditionally considered immensely expensive and the vast majority of people own zero yachts, let alone a collection of them. Note that Randall does not specify how he is trying to get the page locked, and the comic itself might be a rather meta way of doing so: xkcd fans have a history of making lots of edits to Wikipedia articles Randall mentions, resulting in them being protected or locked. The article has in fact been edited and reverted about 50 times by these fans over the course of a single day and was put in temporary protected-status on March 14th, 2019. Protection will end on March 17th, 2019 provided that no other vandalism occurs afterwards.   The first addition of Yachts to this page was by a user named {{w|Special:Contributions/Xkcd2123|Xkcd2123}}, but it is unlikely that this user is Randall.
 ==Transcript==
@@ Line 79: / Line 68: @@
 As of 13 March 2019 at 6:44 PM ET, there ''was'' a debate on the Wikipedia [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:List_of_collectables#May_consider_a_temporary_editing_protection talk] tab about locking this page.
 This has now been upheld, and the page was temporarily locked.
-As of 25 May 2019 at 10:25 PM ET, the page was unlocked and yachts were back on the list.
 A previous comic, [[739: Malamanteau]], also caused a similar situation on Wikipedia, with many xkcd fans attempting to create the fictional page. The page has been turned into a redirect to the Wikipedia page for xkcd.