Talk:3317: Gravitational Square Wave

explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Latest comment: Friday at 14:59 by 204.185.64.131
Jump to navigation Jump to search

I think those pesky astronomers have a bigger thing to worry about. King Pando (talk) 02:49, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

randall out here pushing black holes and neutron stars billions of light-years away from earth GreyFox (talk) 03:50, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

POV Beret Guy is affected by this and just blurs into 2 beret guys This isn't a good name (talk) 03:57, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

If there's someone arranging neutron stars and black holes, I'm going to salute them. The amount of energy required for such a feat is... high enough on the Kardashev scale that it's best not thought about too closely. We wouldn't want there to be two Beret Guys. -2A10:D586:3E93:0:D00:1F9E:F1D7:74FA 08:29, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I'm confused by the string of blocks. What does this represent? SystemParadox (talk) 09:47, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I think it's indicating that space is alternately being squished 'short and wide' and then 'tall and thin'. 86.22.132.121 10:04, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Perhaps these are the "dice" that God does not play with. Mad Marie (talk) 10:38, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
It's likely attempt at showing that squished and stretched cubes exist next to one another (at one given time). The act of stretching and squishing is what happens normally (at ultra-miniscule scale), Randall's "square wave" results in space jumping between the two extremes instantly, there is no stretching, space just becomes stretched and becomes squished. Seeing this would indeed confuse astronomers, and at some (insane) energy would be very "funny" to experience. Maur11cio (talk) 10:58, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Imagine a square cross-section, perpendicular to the source of particularly polarised gravitational waves. As a 'beam' of oscillations moves along that axis of propagation, it makes space-time squash in one cross-sectional direction and stretch in the other. (Note: I think that 'standard' waves squish and stretch both perpendicular directions relative to the axial dimension that stretches and squishes, but I stand to be corrected... and maybe it depends entirely upon the orientation of the gravitational-binaries relative to the observer's direction, so edge-on orbiting does as described.)
For a sinusoidal variation (given the above stipulation) the nominal 'square' will flex taller and thinner and then shorter and wider and back. Viewing the 'box' that is this cross-section across the axial length looks very much like some particularly pretty forms of decorative ironwork bars. But, with a perfect square wave, it'll look like a series of boxes, lined up, alternating tall-and-thin with short-and-wide.
You could also consider a nominally circular cross-section, for either form, which is actually composed of ovals varying/alternating the major and minor axis. The main point is the way this smoothly/sharply transitions, rather than what arbitrary cross-section shape you use, but square/rectangular cross-sections match the square/rectangular 'through-sections' you might also decide to view from sidelong to the 'aimed' gravity-wave.
But it's perhaps harder to describe than visualise. And I'm not sure how I'd be able to do it visual justice better than how the comic displays it. 81.179.198.128 20:06, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

this feels like an answer to a what-if question that was never asked. Lettherebedarklight (talk) 15:37, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

RIP what if 107.1.219.44 16:15, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Lightbulb idea. Are there any universe simulator visualizations/games to test this? If not, xkcd just petitioned all of us to want one! Is there a Universe Creator, like Kerbal, SimCity or Roller Coaster Tycoon? One that I can play with silly physics stuff to see what cosmic phenomenae I can create. An Arcade mode would be for the newbies with gamification of goals ("Kill The Dinosaurs" or "Trigger a Supernova by a Cosmic Deadline" or "Create a Gravity Square Wave"), and a Scientist/Astronomer mode would let me dive deep into things like these. The compute would be extreme, but we now have black hole simulators running in a browser today that looks better than Interstellar (100 hours/frame) running at 10 frames per second on my 5080 GPU. A simplified universe simulation might be possible with clever multi-zoom-levels architecture, combined concurrentyl with the "minimum possible compute" necessary to do this simulation with all kinds of tricks like scientific-neural models and raymarching that is reportedly to dramaticaly speed up simulation. Zoom in, you simulate more (e.g. star has millions of variables) zoom out, you simulate less (e.g. a star might be one variable) at least for a sub-scale "arcade simulation" model sufficient to play with phenomenae like this. And for some of the gamification (dopamine arcade style stuff), you'd have floating measurement windows (energy levels) depending on what you clicked, and you can click Home (which can can have alert icons) to "Observation Lab" on Earth when things are discovered, changes or meets goals, like the discovery of a new planet or a gravity wave or extreme event. We can optimize our math cannons (GPUs). The physics don't have to be perfect. Just want to blow things up that's not typical DOOM games. We don't necessarily need to play with ~10^80-10^85 particles to have something fun that's better than doomscrolling. GDouglas (talk) 20:46, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Does anyone have a closed or non-closed form expression for this wave function? Thanks. ~~ItsMeAMario~~ 169.150.218.79 (talk) 22:44, 29 October 2026 (UTC) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)Reply

Whatever form you like it as, imagine adding together an infinite series of odd-integer harmonic sine wave. With some magnitude reduction, at each stage, of course. 81.179.198.128 23:02, 29 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Lucky enough to be working on square waves today...and... this looks not quite right. The binaries should only be at fundamental spacing. Each would be at an odd harmonic. (NASA engineer) 156.68.251.33 02:32, 30 October 2026 (UTC) 02:30, 30 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Wait - NASA is engineering square waves with black holes?? 86.22.132.121 10:22, 30 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

This clearly and simply shows how a square wave is constructed out of the sum of sine waves https://youtu.be/SpzNQOOBeRg?si=cXoByzkO98v75-6g 2600:1700:25b1:700:88d9:c212:49d2:caf6 (talk) 23:33, 30 October 2026 (UTC) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)Reply

IIUC all the gravitational waves we have detected so far are "chirps" and not steady state waves, so generating a square wave would also be time dependent, and probably not possible since different frequency chirps have different durations and other characteristics. Also IIUC the hopes to detect much weaker longer duration steady states require averaging over many periods and could not distinguish a square wave from a sine wave. There is a general problem that the evolution of a system depends on the rate at which it loses energy, so strong detectable waves will tend to be short lived. Randall needs a different hobby.76.180.39.133 17:31, 31 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I, for one, wouldn't argue with anyone who even could try to have this hobby. I'm not going to tell them that they'd need to try harder to do it correctly. :P 2.98.68.172 21:19, 31 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Since we don't have infinitely precise instruements, can someone try working out how many sets of blackholes and neutron stars you'd need to have a perfect square wave by the standards of our best gravitational wave instruments? Sorry if I worded that horribly. RG (talk) 13:00, 1 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

The known events that create gravity waves use up the masses involved. The emitted waves use up energy and then things fall together and then that source can't generate more gravity waves. So the square wave can't go very long. Also, the image seen is going to depend on the location of the viewer, so the perpetrator of this has to know the Earth is special a long time in advance. 104.251.240.78 13:43, 1 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Fun fact! This isn't mathematically quite possible; a series of waves can never accurately approximate a square function. A Fourier series will converge exponentially if approximating a *smooth* function, but a square function isn't smooth. Instead, the approximation will always have some "ringing" at the discontinuity, and the amplitude of that ringing converges to around 9%. See: The Gibbs Phenomenon. BenWinchester (talk) 15:21, 2 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Another comic about unlikely weaponization of wave phenomena: 967: Prairie 67.0.30.15 21:42, 2 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

Idk i added a one line explanation of what a gravitational wave is. Does it suck? Should it be longer? 204.185.64.131 14:59, 6 November 2026 (UTC)Reply