Talk:976: Sail

explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Latest comment: 25 October by FaviFake
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Really doubting the Armistice Day thing.--Jimmy C (talk) 03:21, 29 November 2012 (UTC)Reply

I agree. I've removed the mention. lcarsos_a (talk) 19:44, 12 December 2012 (UTC)Reply

TWEFI 'questions' and my maybe slightly confused answers:

  • Could this idea actually work in real life, with the right weather conditions?
    • You can blow bubbles purely with wind, yes, just hold the 'activated' bubble-blower wand up in wind within an appropriate range of strengths and let it do the job of you otherwise blowing through it or moving the wand through the air.
  • In this xkcd universe, how do the sails interact with wind?
    • Like sails in our universe?
  • Why is Cueball pulling a line? Is he trying to create the bubble or govern the ship?
    • From where it is shown attached to the boom, in every frame, it's probably just a standard mainsheet line. He lets it go slack to allow the boom to swing round, then holds it to stop it swinging entirely free and uncontrolled, so as to let the sail-bubble extrude properly.
    • Or else it's a halyard of some kind to control the exact "soap bubble wand/rope" that's pretending to be a sail.
  • How would the "soap lagoon" work?
    • It's a lagoon. Full of soapy water. You'd sail in it. And maybe occasionally dunk your mast in it, apparently.

But I get the feeling that the questions need more/different explanation themselves, and that I've not answered what was actually being asked in any of these cases. 78.151.45.31 20:54, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

I tweaked them. They're just there so that new editors are interested in starting to edit our wiki. Feel free to add your own or remove irrelevant ones. FaviFake (talk) 22:15, 17 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
"Is he trying to create the bubble or govern the ship?"
I think from his confused/surprised reaction in the final panel it's clear that he wasn't expecting this behaviour. 86.22.132.121 16:37, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

"Would a boat be able to float in a "soap lagoon"?" Yes. Citation: I put a Lego one-piece boat into a sink full of soapy water and it floated. SCIENCE! 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 06:31, 18 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Thank you for kindly providing your empirical anecdotical evidence, but that alone is not science (apart from the fact that man-sized boats usually are not made of LEGO plastic[citation needed]); rather this is: Vessels float on the surface of fluids, not because of surface tension (which is used, e. g., by water striders indeed), but buoyancy; the latter boils down to the ratio of mean densities in the setting of a homogeneous gravitational field. Now depending on the soap, the soap water has the same density as pure water, give or take, whereas the density of the boat, including everything contained in it, has not changed; ergo the latter would float just fine. To put it differently, the hydrostatics of soap water would not change much compared to pure water—but the hydrodynamics might drastically so because of raised viscosity. – M. L. Juhos 134.60.67.135 07:37, 19 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
397: Unscientific. It's not rigorous, because it wasn't meant to be: it was a reference to some of Randall's footnotes, where he'll state a fact, then say he tested it then and there, and finally cry SCIENCE! - because it's an empirical experiment. It was also a semi-joke. (Follow-up: I wonder what the America's Cup would look like if it had been raced on 5%v dish soap soln...) 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 01:02, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

My first edit (the page did say 'learn by doing'), added some wikipedia citations to make the article internally consistent and tried to expand on the possibility of bubble boat a little bit.Meltro (talk) 07:54, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Welcome to exkcd! Just as a note, we use in-text references and external links here. Thanks for the contribs! 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 17:59, 20 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
I'm glad to know learn by doing had its intended effect! Thanks! FaviFake (talk) 16:51, 23 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
@FaviFake I saw "I'm glad to know Template:Tq is only for quoting in talk and project pages. Do not use it in actual articles. had it's intended effect!" and got 100% confused. I think it's because since {{tq}} is technically on a main page, it throws the error (despite the transclusion). Maybe you should code in an exception? 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 03:28, 24 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
7amithorn Good catch! I removed the mainspace check entirely since all comic discussions are transcluded into the mainspace. I don't think there's an easy way to fix that otherwise. FaviFake (talk) 15:14, 25 October 2026 (UTC)Reply