Difference between revisions of "2034: Equations"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Explanation: ¬HeAt)
(a)
Line 36: Line 36:
 
Quantum gravity uses mathematical {{w|Group (mathematics)|groups}} denoted by uppercase letters, as shown. {{w|Special unitary group|SU(2)}}, {{w|Unitary group|U(1)}}, and {{w|Unitary group|U(2)}} are all well-studied groups, though 'SU(U(2))' makes no sense.  The lack of relator means this expression isn't an equation, but an expression.
 
Quantum gravity uses mathematical {{w|Group (mathematics)|groups}} denoted by uppercase letters, as shown. {{w|Special unitary group|SU(2)}}, {{w|Unitary group|U(1)}}, and {{w|Unitary group|U(2)}} are all well-studied groups, though 'SU(U(2))' makes no sense.  The lack of relator means this expression isn't an equation, but an expression.
  
:[[File:All gauge theory equations.png]]
+
:[[File:All gauge theory equations.png]] <!-- So far, I have S_g=\frac{-1}{2\bar{\varepsilon}}ið\hat{\big(}\xi_0\overset{\circ}{+}\rho_\varepsilon\rho_\text{v}^\text{abc}\cdot\eta_0\hat{\big)}. --!>
 
;All {{w|gauge theory}} equations
 
;All {{w|gauge theory}} equations
 
Gauge theory is a subset of quantum field theory. Because the objects in gauge theory carry a lot of symmetry information, they tend to have a lot of indices and twiddly annotations. Shorthand, such the {{w|Feynman slash}}, is also very common. Although most of the symbols used here do not have specific meanings in gauge theory, &xi; corresponds to the {{w|Gauge fixing#Rξ gauges|Rξ gauges}} in quantum electrodynamics, and the  "abc" superscript is reminiscent of a {{w|structure constant}}.
 
Gauge theory is a subset of quantum field theory. Because the objects in gauge theory carry a lot of symmetry information, they tend to have a lot of indices and twiddly annotations. Shorthand, such the {{w|Feynman slash}}, is also very common. Although most of the symbols used here do not have specific meanings in gauge theory, &xi; corresponds to the {{w|Gauge fixing#Rξ gauges|Rξ gauges}} in quantum electrodynamics, and the  "abc" superscript is reminiscent of a {{w|structure constant}}.

Revision as of 16:45, 19 December 2025

Equations
All electromagnetic equations: The same as all fluid dynamics equations, but with the 8 and 23 replaced with the permittivity and permeability of free space, respectively.
Title text: All electromagnetic equations: The same as all fluid dynamics equations, but with the 8 and 23 replaced with the permittivity and permeability of free space, respectively.

Explanation

This comic gives a set of mock equations. To anyone not familiar with the field in question they look pretty similar to what you might find in research papers or on the relevant Wikipedia pages. Most of the jokes are related to the symbols or "look" of most equations in the given field.

The comic makes jokes about the fields of kinematics, number theory, fluid dynamics, quantum mechanics, chemistry, quantum gravity, gauge theory, cosmology, and physics equations. Of course, all of the equations listed are not real equations (\pi-\infty and H2EAT are clearly jokes and making a mockery of the given field). As always, Randall is just having a laugh.

E=K_{0}t+\frac{1}{2}\rho{}vt^2
All kinematics equations

Most kinematics equations are polynomials, usually at most quadratic, and are often integral quantities (corresponding to the 1/2 t^2 term). This specific equation resembles the actual kinematics equation d = vt + 1/2at^2, but replaces a (acceleration) with v (velocity) times \rho{} (density) and replaces velocity with "K0", which is not a term used in kinematics.

K_{n}=\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\sum_{\pi=0}^{\infty}(n-\pi)(i+e^{\pi-\infty})
All number theory equations

Number theory is the study of the integers and their properties. Randall jokes about how this often involves the use of summations over integers. The subscripts are indices, but the use of π as a summation index is a joke — π is almost always used for the well-known constant 3.14159..., not a variable. The use of i as a summation variable is common, but the joke is that when it appears along with the constant e, as it does here it usually represents the imaginary unit √-1. As well, the constant e is out-of-place in a field like number theory — it's more closely related to fields like calculus/analysis. The use of the symbol \infty as a literal is also a joke.

\frac{\partial}{\partial{t}}\nabla\!\cdot\!\rho=\frac{8}{23}\int\!\!\!\!\int\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\subset\!\!\supset\rho\,{ds}\,{dt}\cdot{}\rho\frac{\partial}{\partial\nabla}
All fluid dynamics equations

Fluid dynamics equations often involve copious use of vector calculus operators. It's common in field theories like fluid dynamics and electromagnetism to represent equations of motion using multidimensional operators, like the \nabla and closed contour integral ∮ which appear here. The fraction 8/23 is a comically weird choice, but various unexpected fractions do pop up in fluid dynamics. The ds and dt go with the double contour integral (s is probably distance, t is time), but the derivative with respect to \nabla at the end is very much a joke and not allowed.

|\psi_{x,y}\rangle=A(\psi)A(|x\rangle\otimes|y\rangle)
All quantum mechanics equations

Quantum mechanics often involves some of the foreign-looking symbols listed, including bra-ket notation, the tensor product, and the Greek letter Psi for a quantum state. Specifically, the left side of the equation is a ket state labeled Psi that depends on x and y (probably positions), while the right-hand side may be an operator A that depends on the state Psi (it is very unusual to have such a dependence) acting on what looks like another copy of that operator which depends on the outer product of states labeled by x and y (again strange). A charitable interpretation could be that the second A is the eigenfunction A of the operator A. Normally this is clearly indicated by giving the operator a “hat” (^ symbol) or making the eigenfunction into a ket eigenstate, but since the equation is intentionally nonsense both A’s are left ambiguous. Also note that the bra-ket math is inconsistent here, as the left side is a ket, but the right side is just two A’s, which are either operators or functions but are definitely not kets.

CH_4+OH+HEAT\rightarrow{}H_2O+CH_{2}+H_2EAT
All chemistry equations

Chemistry equations use formulas of chemical compounds to describe a chemical reaction. Such equations show the starting chemicals on the left side and the resulting products on the right side, as displayed. Sometimes such an equation might optionally indicate that an activation energy is required, for the reaction to take place in a sensible timeframe, e.g. by heating. A reaction requiring heating is usually indicated by a Greek capital letter Delta (Δ) or a specified temperature above the reaction arrow, however this comic uses the "+ HEAT" term on the left side instead. The joke is that Randall interprets "HEAT" to be another chemical which reacts with Hydrogen (H) to H2EAT, which is nonsensical, as heat is transferred energy here, not added matter. Regardless of this, Randall gets the stoichiometry of this equation correct, with the same number of all types of 'atoms' on each side of the equation.

SU(2)U(1)\times{}SU(U(2))
All quantum gravity equations

Quantum gravity uses mathematical groups denoted by uppercase letters, as shown. SU(2), U(1), and U(2) are all well-studied groups, though 'SU(U(2))' makes no sense. The lack of relator means this expression isn't an equation, but an expression.

All gauge theory equations.png