2970: Meteor Shower PSA

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Revision as of 10:22, 10 August 2024 by Kynde (talk | contribs) (Transcript: complete)
Jump to: navigation, search
Meteor Shower PSA
If you hold the meteor too long, it may imprint on you and form a contact binary, making reintroduction to space difficult.
Title text: If you hold the meteor too long, it may imprint on you and form a contact binary, making reintroduction to space difficult.

Explanation

Ambox warning blue construction.svg This is one of 53 incomplete explanations:
Created by a REHABILITATED BOT ABOUT TO BE RELEASED BACK INTO THE WILD - Please change this comment when editing this page. Do NOT delete this tag too soon. If you can fix this issue, edit the page!

In this comic, Randall conflates meteors from the upcoming Perseid meteor shower with rehabilitating baby animals. Like he says, if you find a sick, injured or orphaned wild animal, your best bet is to ask a nearby wildlife rehabilitator to care for it and return it to the wild. However, this advice does not apply to meteors.[citation needed]

The title text says that if you handle the meteor too long you'll form a contact binary, which in this context is two space rocks lumped together. A contact binary is also a type of binary star system, but it's unlikely that a person and a rock will form this.[citation needed] In the process of rehabilitating young animals, preventing imprinting is important as the animal cannot rely on the human caregiver to succeed in the wild.

Technically, Randall has the terminology wrong. "Meteor" refers to the shooting star you see in the sky when a meteoroid enters the atmosphere. If it makes it to the ground, the piece that survives is called a "meteorite" (although some call it magma).

Transcript

[A two panel comic with the panels next to each other.]
[In the left side of the first panel, Cueball spots a meteorite on the ground. It lies a bit buried in the earth between tufts of grass. On the right side, he's shown throwing the rock into the air, with small lines indicating the flight of the meteorite. There's an "X" above him. Above this there is the following text:]
This meteor shower weekend, remember: If you find a meteor on the ground, don't try to return it to the sky yourself.
[In the left side of the second panel, Cueball is holding the meteorite in one hand and talking on his cellphone in his other hand, there's a check mark above him. In the middle of the panel Cueball is holding the meteorite out in both hands handing it to Ponytail who is also holding both hand out to receive it. To the right in the panel a rocket is blasting upwards with fire coming out beneath it and a plume of smoke showing it's ascend path. Above this there is the following text:]
Instead, contact an observatory where astronomical rehabbers will care for it, and hopefully release it back into the wild with the next space launch.

comment.png  Add comment      new topic.png  Create topic (use sparingly)     refresh discuss.png  Refresh 

Discussion

Pretty sure the term "contact binary" in this instance is referring to the small solar system body variety (a peanut asteroid) rather than a contact binary star, but I can't think of a way to explain that in the explanation.RegularSizedGuy (talk) 06:11, 10 August 2024 (UTC)

Are there any known examples of a contact binary star? Elektrizikekswerk (talk) 11:24, 12 August 2024 (UTC)

Amongst other things, if you ever see a space-rock fall, and land, don't be tempted to just pick it up. It will probably be extremely cold, for a while. And you don't want to leave your sticky fingerprints on it (or, maybe, its sticky fingerprints on you). If you have a handy (clean) container then perhaps you could scoop it up to stop it from getting lost/soiled where it lies, unless you get more immediate advice directly from experts who might be very interested. (Depends upon who you talk to, and when, but there may be some standing advice that you can follow, if you're not lucky enough to already be an expert in the subject out looking for a particular find.) 172.71.26.87 14:09, 10 August 2024 (UTC)

It seems to me that the "more dangerous examples" should link to something along the lines of SF stories in which infectious material came to Earth via meteorite. The "Green Rocks" link is more about how sci-fi (term used advisedly) alien substances (including meteorites) can have any magic powers the plot needs. I'm trying to come up with examples, but all that's coming to mind immediately is Walter M. Miller Jr.'s "Dark Benediction". BunsenH (talk) 01:07, 11 August 2024 (UTC)

I (as that editor, and of the prior comment here) had the same difficulty. Even a wikiwalk (or, indeed, a tvtropeswalk) didn't seem to give what I thought was there. I mention the Venom symbiote, above (a near-example; most cases of it, in various continuities, seem to have it being brought to Earth... if it 'fell in the open' it was part of a sample-return mission crashing and burning), and there are a number of other "mysterious rock falls which 'infects' the locals who find it and touch it" (much parodied and repeated) but I could not find the unambiguous ur-example or whatever 'famously made it famous' in any real sense.
Green Rocks does have a lot of (obvious) memetic overlap with Smallville and similar treatments around that continuity/canon. (I was mostly worrying that in that case, Clarke aside, pretty much everyone who got 'green rocked' at least at first found the effects beneficial ...it's where they took that, and/or hidden psychological compulsions, that might have been their ultimate downfall. Or at least quickly found themselves uniquely isolated from society due to unwanted death-prognistication skills/whatever.)
It was just a bit of a chuck-it-in, really. Had also been looking at non-meteoric examples. Such as if a soviet satellite's RTG landed, 'intact', you might be wise not to just hold it, or the fictional nuclear weapon discovered by farmers in Sum Of All Fears, or the non-fictional (but not 'loaded') real-life equivalent that luckily wasn't as dangerous as a true Broken Arrow would have been.
So make of it what you want. I tried to keep the Explanation aside short and sweet, rather than overly explain the joke, but doubtless someone else can refine it (or excise it) in ways that I never found able to. 172.70.163.121 12:11, 11 August 2024 (UTC)
Andromeda Strain? JohnHawkinson (talk) 02:24, 12 August 2024 (UTC)

The bit in the explanation stating that animals might abandon their young if it smells of humans should be removed. That's a myth. --172.71.22.155 03:22, 11 August 2024 (UTC)

With regard to the "More dangerous examples" suggestion/request may I recommend the short story 'Meteor' by John Wyndham? 172.69.60.136 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)
      comment.png  Add comment