132: Music Knowledge

Music Knowledge

|< < Prev #132 (July 24, 2006) Next > >|

Title text: When Guitar Hero 2 comes out I'll have fresh conversational material for MONTHS.

|< < Prev Random Explanation Next > >|

Explanation

The punchline of this comic is that just by naming bands from the game Guitar Hero, you can sound pretty knowledgeable about music without actually knowing anything about the bands you are naming. This is further emphasized when Megan mentions Metallica, a very famous band that mostly everyone can be assumed to have heard of, and Cueball has no clue who they are, because Metallica is not featured in Guitar Hero (at the time of this comic writing).

In the title text, Cueball (or possibly Randall) is just hoping for a sequel to Guitar Hero to get more, and newer, conversational material.

Transcript

[Megan and Cueball converse.]

Megan: What kind of music do you listen to?

Cueball: Oh, a mix of things. Some classic rock like Boston, but then of course Queen and Bowie, Joan Jett...

Megan: Definitely, we need more of those sounds.

Cueball: But there's some great newer stuff too, like Franz Ferdinand, The Donnas, and Audioslave.

Megan: Sometimes they're a little much for me. I go more for things like The Arcade Fire, sometimes mixing some electronic sounds like Postal Service.

Cueball: Oh yeah—have you ever checked out Freezepop?

Megan: Mhm! Synth pop can be fun, but at the same time, I agree that sometimes you just need to blast some Metallica.

Cueball: Who?

Megan: ...Metallica.

Cueball: Are they new?

I sound pretty knowledgeable about music until people figure out that I'm just naming bands from Guitar Hero.

Trivia

• In his Google-speech in late 2007, Randall expressed some form of dissatisfaction with Guitar Hero III (coincidentally the first edition in the series to include a Metallica song).
• In 2009, three years after this comic was released, Metallica eventually got a game Guitar Hero: Metallica.

  Add comment        Create topic (use sparingly)       Refresh 

Discussion

It may be worth noting that much of Freezepop's popularity comes from one of the band members being the music director for Guitar Hero and related games and slipping in their own songs. This got them an audience way beyond most synthpop bands (and I'm sure endorsements by people like Randall didn't hurt).

Of course the rest of their popularity comes from the fact that they wrote great music, made cute videos, and put on a fun live show. And that synthpop is just better than whatever you listen to. 162.158.255.69 23:37, 16 September 2015 (UTC)

He's not endorsing them, he's saying the name because he doesn't know how else to respond to the character's comment.—Kazvorpal (talk) 01:57, 21 September 2019 (UTC)

Oh, please. Queen, Bowie, and Joan blow Freezepop out of the water

^agreed.

This comic reminded me of the "technical school mathematician incident" in China. The student's "math knowledge" (similar to the "music knowledge" in this comic) was questioned. ConscriptGlossary (talk) 11:34, 8 November 2024 (UTC)

You sound like we should know all about this. Maybe I'm an exception, but I can only very roughly guess what you're alluding to. (I'm guessing you're in, or from, China and it was huge national news there?) 172.71.26.61 14:01, 8 November 2024 (UTC)

Just now I found that her name was blocked by the search engine. The student made a lot of mistakes in her handwriting. It's not blurry - it's clearly wrong. The latest piece of news about her came out on November 3. ConscriptGlossary (talk) 08:50, 9 November 2024 (UTC)

Yeah, I hear that there can be "keyword filtering" over there when deemed necessary. Of course, we're probably more likely to hear about naval. incidents (or at least more likely to see documented cases about which ships nudged which other ships, etc) or what's happening to certain ethnic minorities, than the kind of thing you must he refering to. (For the sake of not making it troublesome for you, I'll avoid mentioning directly the more specific names/places/dates that might trigger the Great Firewall and/or deplete your 'social credit' if you're not already taking precautions against such scrutiny.)

I did a bit of searching for stories about this kind of thing, but could only come up with more generic recent problems (e.g. withdrawl of Advanced Placement results, for whole swathes of students), on top of several years of similar concerns that the system wasn't really consistent/satisfactory in the 'oversees' academic world. Sometimes it was seen as the parents(/students) trying to dodge the system, sometimes it was a 'higher up' systemic misrepresentation (achievement targets and quotas trying to be met?). Obviously it won't be in isolation, and not be uniquely one thing (nor internationally the only such problem spot). And no wonder that a more specific case of cheating(?) just doesn't notably pop up on our radar, here. I'm sure it's a fun story, but we'll just have to use our imaginations! 172.70.162.39 11:39, 9 November 2024 (UTC)

her initials are jp 172.71.26.100 12:01, 9 November 2024 (UTC)
        Add comment